Stability Analysis

Authors
Affiliations

University of Washington

Juliet N. Nakakawa

Makerere University

Doreen M. Ssebuliba

Kyambogo University

Here, we describe several ways of computing threshold conditions for this basic malaria model:

\[ \begin{array}{rl} \frac{dX}{dt} = F_X(Y) &= bfq\frac{Y}{H}(H-X) - r X \\ \frac{dY}{dt} = F_Y(X) &= cfq \frac{X}{H} (M-Y) - g Y \end{array} \]

Steady States

We note that the system has two steady states. The disease-free steady state is at \(X=Y=0.\)

To compute the endemic equilibrium, let \(x = X/H\) and \(y=Y/M.\) At the steady state,

\[y = \frac{cfqx}{g + cfqx}\]

and substituting this back, we get

\[\frac{dx}{dt} = bcf^2 q^2 \frac{x}{g+cfqx}(1-x) - rx = 0\]

We let

\[R_0 = bc \frac{M}{H} \frac{f^2 q^2}{gr}\]

A recurring term is the expected number of times a mosquito would get infected in its lifetime, assuming humans are perfectly infectious: \[s=cfq/g\]

Since we’re not at \(x=0\), we can divide by \(x,\) rewrite and simplify

\[R_0 (1-x) = 1+s\] Collecting and solving for \(x\), we get

\[ x = \frac{R_0-1}{R_0 + s} \] substituting this back, we get

\[ y = \frac{R_0-1}{R_0} \frac{s}{1+s} \]

Stability Analysis

To evaluate the stability of these equilbria, we compute the matrix of partial derivatives:

\[ R = \left[ \begin{array}{rl} \frac{\partial F_X}{dX} & \frac{\partial F_X}{dY} \\ \frac{\partial F_Y}{dX} & \frac{\partial F_Y}{dY} \end{array} \right] = \left[ \begin{array}{rl} - bfq\frac{Y}{H} - r& bfq \frac{H-X}{H} \\ cfq\frac{M-Y}{H} & - cfq \frac{X}{H} - g \end{array} \right] \]

Effectively, we are looking at the stability of the linearized system at these steady states.

If we evaluate \(R\) at the disease-free equilibrium, \(X_0=Y_0=0.\)

\[ \left. R \right|_{X=Y=0} = \left[ \begin{array}{rl} - r& bfq \\ cfq\frac{M}{H} & - g \end{array} \right] \] The eigenvalues of a matrix are negative if and only if the trace is negative and the determinant is positive. Since the trace of \(R\) is negative (using mathematical notation, \(\mbox{Tr}\left(R\right) = - r - g\)), the determinant must be positive. The disease free state is stable (meaning the parasite will not increase) only if: \[ \mbox{det}\left(R\right) = rg - bc f^2 q^2 \frac{M}{H} > 0 \] It follows that the disease free state is unstable (and the parasite will increase) only if:

\[ R_0 = bc \frac{f^2 q^2}{rg} \frac{M}{H} > 1. \]

Eigenvalues & Eigenvectors

We can find the eigenvalues (vectors \(E\) and scalars \(\ell\) that satisfy \(R \cdot x = \ell x\)), by computing

\[ \mbox{det}\left[ \begin{array}{rl} - r-\ell& bfq \\ cfq\frac{M}{H} & - g -\ell \end{array} \right] = \ell^2 + \ell \; \mbox{Tr}\left(R\right) + \mbox{det}\left(R\right) = 0 \] or

\[ \ell = \frac{- \mbox{Tr}\left(R\right) \pm \sqrt{\mbox{Tr}\left(R\right)^2 - 4 \; \mbox{det}\left(R\right)} }{2} \]

If we let \(E_1\) be the eigenvector associated with the larger eignvalue (\(\ell_1\)) and \(E_2\) the other one (associated with eigenvalue \(\ell_2\)), then we can write any initial vector \(X_0, Y_0\) as a linear combination:

\[\left[\begin{array}{r} X_0 \\ Y_0 \end{array} \right] = \xi_1 E_1 + \xi_2 E_2 \]

Then

\[e^{Rt} = \xi_1 \ell_1^t E_1 + \xi_2 \ell_2^t E_2\]

Next Generation Matrix