ANTHROPOLOGY 550
ETHNOGRAPHIC FIELD METHODS


MF 1:30-3:20, Denny 401

Readings for Friday, Nov 7
The El Dorado Thing

Course Home
E-mail the class
Class discussion board

FRIDAY HISTORICAL READINGS
Oct 10: Pioneers
Oct 17: Expertise
Oct 24: Cliffords
Oct 31: Danger
Nov 7: El Dorado
Nov 14: Emotions
Nov 21: Natives
M Dec 1: Assistants
Dec 5: Summary


MONDAY EXERCISES
Sep 29: Experience
Oct 6: Observation
Oct 13: Interview
Oct 20: Discomfort
Oct 27: Formal
Nov 3: Survey
Nov 10: Photo
Nov 17: Video
Nov 24: Digital
El Dorado! Let's plunge headlong into the most intense and vitriolic controversy about fieldwork and fieldwork ethics that has ever plagued the discipline of anthropology. I once taught a whole course on this, but for today we just get a sampling. Napoleon Chagnon did extensive fieldwork under trying circumstances among the Yanomami or Yanomamo in Venezuela and Brazil, wrote probably the best-selling anthropology book ever, and was widely accused of seriously unethical behavior in the field, something he resolutely denies.

Read the following:
  • Napoleon Chagnon, First Contact with the Mishimishimaboweiteri from Studying the Yanomamo
  • Patrick Tierney, Chapter 2, The Napoleonic Wars, from Darkness in El Dorado
  • Robert Borowski, Chapters 2 and 3, How the Controversy has Played Out, and Broader Issues at Stake, from Yanomami: The Fierce Controversy
  • Clifford Geertz, Life Among the Anthros

  • Then, by midnight on Thursday, Nov 6, post a comment of about 200 words on anything you want to say about the El Dorado issue. I don't think I need to give you much of a prompt, but please try to stay rational, don't just join the chorus of condemnations or the chorus of exonerations, and think of the wider implications of the controversy.