Email the Class
Essay Assignment for the Forest Resources Unit
Write 1500-2000 words on one of the following topics:
Due 5:00 p.m. Monday, April 27
A. It is clear from our readings, lectures, and field trip that forests have multiple uses (wood products, energy, and a variety of ecosystem services), and that these uses are often in conflict with each other. It is also clear that these conflicts are not just scientific and ecological, but also political. Given what you know about the Eastside or dry side forests of Washington and Oregon, what principles would you use to design a policy for balancing these different uses of forests? You do not need to develop a plan, but rather you need to set out the ecological, economic, and cultural uses of these forest lands, the particular stakeholders that are likely to favor particular uses, and the overall costs and benefits of emphasizing one use over another for sustainability and resilience at the system scale.
B. A lot of management and planning for forest lands depends on understanding the past history of such lands (as the USFS has done at the national scale, Hessburg and Agee have done for the Eastside forests in general, and the Yakama Nation has done for its own forests), and then projecting how this history might inform what we expect to happen in the near future (as the USFS did in its Future of America's Forests and Rangelands report and the Yakama Nation has done with its own Forest Management Plans). There are many potential pitfalls with such a strategy, including incomplete historical knowledge, the hypothetical nature of scenarios, the general unpredictability of the future, and the tendency of managers to follow plans less adaptively than they might. Analyze each of these (and other) weaknesses of this strategy of planning as it applies to the Eastside forests. Then consider whether there is any alternative: if so, what is it, and if not, why not?
C. In recent years, scientists, historians, and managers have come to appreciate that traditional land managers, including native peoples who manage according to traditional ecological knowledge (TEK), have often managed natural resources in more sustainable or resilient ways than have professional managers. At the same time, not all the situations of forest management that we now face (see, for example, the USFS report, the Yakama forest management plans, and your field trip notes) have precedents in traditional knowledge and the practices associated with it. For the Eastside forests, what and how should managers and the public learn from traditional management by Native Americans, and in what aspects of forest management (ecological, economic, and cultural) is there not enough relevant Native experience that can be applied, and why not?
D. There are two ways to attempt to preserve or increase ecosystem services (see the definitions given in the introductory article by Farley and Constanza). One is by regulation: recognizing that an area (a forest, lake, wetland, etc.) provides ecosystem services, we prohibit degrading it, and impose fines or other penalties for violating the prohibition. The other is so-called Payment for Ecosystem Services. Property owners or stakeholders can be paid for providing the services (as in federal payments to owners of marginal cropland if they leave the land fallow), or they can be charged for the services (such as carbon taxes levied on GHG emitters for deforestation, or charging airplane passengers for the GHG emitted in flight). You have seen some of the ecosystem services provided by forests in Washington, both in your readings and on your field trip. Most measures to preserve these services are in the form of regulation. What would be the advantage or disadvantage of adopting a PES, market-like framework to supplant or supplement regulation? Give specific examples or scenarios.
Essays should be between 1500 and 2000 words in length, not counting bibliographic references. You may use any style (footnotes, endnotes, or embedded author and date) for references, as long as it is clear where you have gotten your information. Quotations should always be referenced, as should any information that is taken explicitly from a given source.