This Version: 22 February 2015
Scholars suggest that importing countries are able to project their regulatory standards onto their exporters abroad. This paper explores the possibility of a Shanghai Effect whereby African countries begin to reflect the labor practices of China, which has emerged as a major destination for their exports. Introducing a novel compositional data approach to the analysis of trade-context effects on exporting countries, we show that when a country increases exports to China, the net effect of that trade on domestic labor standards depends critically on the labor practices of other export destinations compositionally displaced by trade with China. We examine counterfactual effects of an increase in trade with China under different “replacement rules”: the manner and extent to which China compositionally replaces other export destinations. Our analysis of a panel of 49 African countries for the period 1985–2010 suggests a small continent-wide estimate of China’s negative influence on African labor practices. Because these continent-level estimates mask considerable variation at the country level, our further analyses reveal modest Shanghai Effects for a handful of African countries only.
Reports and Unpublished Papers
This Version: 6 October 2011
Several estimators from the social science toolkit might be used to model the relationship between imprecisely-observed ranks in a hierarchy, and covariates explaining those ranks. But application of standard methods–such as linear regression, ordered probit, or censored regression–is complicated by the interdependence of rank observations. Monte Carlo evidence shows that estimators which either delete partially observed ranks and/or inappropriately assume ranks are iid perform poorly, yielding inefficient and sometimes biased estimates, and wildly inaccurate confidence intervals. In contrast, a Bayesian partial rank model–designed to impute missing ranks within known bounds, and account for interdependence across ranks–performs well, even when most or all ranks are observed imprecisely.
Submitted May 12, 2005 to the Superior Court of Chelan County, Washington
Expert witness report on ecological inference and the statistical analysis of elections in Borders v. King County, which contested the 2004 Washington gubernatorial election. The final (unappealed) ruling in favor of Governor Christine Gregoire can be found here. Wikipedia's entry on the 2004 Washington election can be found here, though I cannot vouch for the validity of wiki content.
March 19, 2005
with David M. Butler and Sven E. Wilson
Political scientists often and increasingly analyze time-series cross-sectional (tscs) data. These data come with significant problems, such as accounting for unobserved variation across sample units and appropriately specifying dynamics. Furthermore, even though fixed-effects (or least squares dummy variable (lsdv) models) can address unit heterogeneity, least squares (ls) estimation of modelds with fixed-effects and lagged dependent variables are known to be biased. Alternative estimators, mostly from economics, and generally designed for short panels, have been proposed to address this bias, but it is generally not well known how these estimators perform in comparison to simple methods like ls and lsdv on tscs data. The preliminary results we illustrate here suggest that lsdv is generally as good or better than instrumental variables (iv) approaches in terms of bias and efficiency. We examine estimator performance under conditions where the importance of the unit effects and the correlation of the unit effects with the independent variables are allowed to vary and find that lsdv performs well. Unfortunately none of the estimators, particularly ls, perform well when the dynamics of the model are mis-specified. The lesson is that new estimators do not, in general, solve the problem of mis-specifying the model’s dynamics.
October 12, 2002
In recent years, homeowner associations (hoas) in Harris County, Texas have ﬁled thousands of lawsuits threatening foreclosure against residents who owed dues, late fees, or ﬁnes. An event count analysis of hoa foreclosures by neighborhood from 1985—2001 shows the bulk of these ﬁlings occur in neighborhoods with low median home values. Overall, homeowners in the bottom quartile of home value face more than ten times the risk of hoa foreclosure proceedings as those in the top quartile. Legal changes in 1987 and 1995 also seem to have encouraged hoas to bring more foreclosures to court: across the spectrum of home values, the annual pace of ﬁling after 1995 is roughly double the previous decade’s rate. Although hoa foreclosures are ostensibly motivated by efforts to improve property values, neither foreclosure activity nor hoas appear linked with above average home price growth.
Replication: Data are drawn from HOAdata, which should be consulted for more recent data.