University of Washington
Department of Geography
Professor Harrington
Geographic Information and Economic Development
 

Key to local or regional economic development is complementing immobile or less-mobile characteristics1 of an area with mobile components such as technology and financial capital.  Therefore, current information about regional characteristics benefits those whose interests are the economic well-being of the region, as well as those whose interests may be served by investing in or purchasing from the region.
 

Contents:
Economic development
Microeconomic decisions
Macroeconomic analysis

 
ECONOMIC  DEVELOPMENT is commonly defined as a change in the economic sectors or relationships among economic sectors in a region (at the scale of a metropolitan area, a part of a large national territory, or a national territory2).  The study of economic development requires both MICRO-ECONOMIC ANALYSIS (understanding the investment decisions of firms, the purchasing decisions of households, businesses, and governments, and the employment decisions of individuals) and MACRO-ECONOMIC ANALYSIS (understanding the ways in which wage rates, interest rates, and exchange rates operate and affect aggregate outcomes such as employment levels, regional production, inter-regional and international trade flows).  Because these decisions and results occur partially because of interaction among places, they are inherently geographic.  (Optional:  see related notes).
 


GEOGRAPHIC  INFORMATION  AND  MICRO-ECONOMIC  DECISIONS

Most of the economic uses of geographic information that make use of GIS are micro-economic:


The Boyles book reports on a website that provides information to all regarding location of real-estate and location opportunities within a particular city.  The city's purpose is to reduce the cost to potential entrepreneurs, corporations, and investors who might benefit from such information and decide to locate economic activities within the city.
Take a look at this website:  what features does it have that support retail market analysis?  What types of retail market analysis are supported?  What ideas does the website give you regarding the use of geographic information and GIS for industrial location analysis?

The Boyles book reports on a website that provides information to all regarding employment and training opportunities, detailed workforce characteristics, and tips for seeking employment.  The city's purpose is to increase the likelihood that someone looking for (different) employment in the city can find it, and to reduce the cost to existing and potential employers of identifying workers.
 


GEOGRAPHIC  INFORMATION  AND  MACRO-ECONOMIC  ANALYSIS

The major instruments of macro-economic policy at the national scale are interest rates, counter-cyclical fiscal spending (e.g., unemployment benefits that sustain household demand in times of high unemployment), currency valuation, and trade policy.

Almost by definition, sub-national regions (states, provinces, metropolitan areas, municipalities) do not have most of these instruments.  (Even state unemployment programs cannot be truly counter-cyclical, to the extent that most states must balance their annual fiscal budgets).

So sub-national regions attempt to improve their immobile assets (labor forces, physical infrastructures, tax policies) so as to attract mobile assets (financial capital, highly skilled workers, households with external incomes (tourists, retirees)).3  How might a state government or local chamber of commerce know what mobile assets to attract, and how to improve immobile assets to be attractive?

  1. Decide that any external investment is good, and try to keep wages and taxes low to attract any investment (also known as "smokestack chasing")
  2. Target specific, mobile assets because they're highly valued by everyone (tourism, "high tech")
  3. Assess current strengths relative to other regions, identify mobile assets that benefit from those strengths, reinforce those current strengths, and attract relevant mobile assets.
The third option motivates the current economic-development excitement over "clusters."

AGGLOMERATIONa higher-than-average concentration of particular economic activities in some regions (compared to others).  (Also see Geog 207 notes).  Agglomerations could result from

INDUSTRIAL  DISTRICT is a phrase often used to describe a set of related producers in close proximity who benefit from intensive interactions (employee movements;  technical conversations) and purchases (inputs, consultations, financing) from each other.  This is a special type of agglomeration, and this older phrase is essentially what is meant by the newer term CLUSTER.

How does the ESRI article use the term "cluster"?  Compare this to the Colgan and Baker article.
Relate Porter's "diamond model" [Colgan and Baker, p. 353] to the idea of mobile and immobile assets.
Compare Porter's "diamond" to Colgan and Baker's "dimensions of clusters."
What clusters do Colgan and Baker identify in Maine?  What happened when they took this analysis through the political process?  What policy measures was the State of Maine considering to strengthen clusters?  What measures could other actors (municipalities, colleges, universities, chambers of commerce) take?
Given the other articles assigned for this unit, how might GIS be used to assist Colgan and Baker's analysis?
Take a look at this link.  How might this relate to one of Colgan and Baker's findings?
What clusters has Seattle's mayor focused on?  Look at this link and this link (in the latter, note the link to a study performed by Professor Bill Beyers).
 
 




Notes:
1.  What are some key non- or less-mobile characteristics of a metropolitan area?  Of a large region of a country?  Of a nation-state?
2.  We could analyze economic development for some non-territorial unit, such as African Americans (as entrepreneurs, landowners, employees, and consumers) across the U.S. or within a metropolitan area.
3.  Does this (somewhat artificial) distinction between immobile and mobile assets remind you of any other framework?  Do you find it useful?  Why and why not?


copyright James W. Harrington, Jr.
revised 16 February 2004