University
of Washington
Geography
207
Professor
Harrington
Why Cities?
Contents:
WHY DOES ECONOMIC ACTIVITY
CONCENTRATE IN CITIES?
-
division of labor: from (a) self-sufficient subsistence to
(b) specialization and market exchange, which is easier with proximity
of the specialized actors and producers
-
provision of physical infrastructure (transport rights-of-way, utilities)
at lower cost when the users are close together
-
information exchange: proximity was necessary before the telegraph;
proximity still assists the transfer of subtle information, such as attitude
MEASURING THE BENEFITS AND
COSTS OF ECONOMIC AND GEOGRAPHIC CONCENTRATION
externalities: benefits or costs of a firm’s actions that
are not captured or borne by the firm that is responsible for them
(See Hanink, pp.119-22; S&deS, pp.279-82)
positive externalities of urbanization ("urbanization economies"
in
Hanink, pp.313-4)
-
shared labor force
-
specialized labor force
-
specialized services
-
shared infrastructure
-
easier flow of information
negative externalities of urbanization
-
land costs, leading to higher cost of living, leading to higher wages
-
congestion, leading to higher costs of transportation (esp. in terms of
time)
-
pollution (would exist anywhere, but density reduces the natural environment’s
ability to dissipate pollutants)
-
resource depletion, because of the intensity of resource use (link
to brief article on Mexico City)
INTERNAL VERSUS EXTERNAL ECONOMIES
Internal economies of scale: reductions in unit costs of
production as a result of larger designed scale of output within the firm;
note that this entails a shift (downward) of a given marginal-cost curve
(supply curve), rather than a movement along the same (short-run) marginal-cost
curve; note that this is a benefit to the firm based on actions of
the firm
Sources (the first two are the most important, because they rely
on designed capacity, rather than short-run increases in output):
-
specialized machinery, leading to greater capital and labor productivity
-
finer division of labor, leading to greater labor productivity
-
spread of fixed costs over greater output (management, research)
-
purchasing power
-
(monopoly power is usually considered separately, not as a production issue)
External economies of agglomeration: reductions in unit
costs of production as a result of proximity or density of economic activity;
note that this is a benefit to the whole, from the actions of individual
firms.
(a) external economies of urbanization: agglomeration
economies based on location in an urban area
Sources:
see the external economies and diseconomies of cities, above
(b) external economies of localization: agglomeration
economies based on the proximity of similar producers
Sources:
-
specialized labor force
-
transfer of specialized information (often through the labor force)
-
joint support of specialized services
-
political clout
copyright James W. Harrington, Jr.
revised 5 May 2000