University of Washington
Geography 349:  Geography of International Trade

Response papers 2 & 3


Read (as assigned in the syllabus):
Optionally, you may find it useful to skim
Students who are turning in drafts of Tasks 2 & 3 on Monday 16 October should also undertake and turn in Response paper 2, described below.  Other students should undertake and turn in Response paper 3, described below.  You'll have time in class to exchange the insights that you gained.


Response paper 2
Read Batra's Chapter 6 and Krugman's Chapter 3 (you'll probably also make use of the instructor's online notes on trade theory and trade policy).  Select two of the countries that Batra profiles in Chapter 6.  In about 500 words, encapsulate the trade policies, trade and FDI outcomes, and economic well-being of those two countries.  Then, in about 250 words, try to generalize about the impacts of different trade policies.  Finally, in about 250 words, tell me how and why your empirical generalization supports or does not support neoclassical trade theory.  These word totals are only rough, rough guidelines.

I'll restate the same assignment in different words.  Write a 4-5-page double spaced paper in which you compare the trade experiences of two countries, in each case, relating the trends and effects of trade to the country's trade policies;  then in that same paper, tell me what you think those two cases show about the effects of different trade policies;  then tell me whether this is consonant with the basic model of trade, trade impacts, and trade policy that we studied over the past several days.  This experience will give you some background for your team's presecriptions for trade policies for the country your team is studying.

Please bring five copies of this to class on the 16th, so you can exchange them with your team mates. 

Before the mid-term, please also read Krugman's Chapters 4 and 8, and make sure you get an understanding of Batra's arguments in Chapters 8, 9, and 12 -- from our class discussions, the papers and comments of your team members, and/or from reading those chapters yourself.


Response paper 3
Read all three of Krugman's chapters (they're short and non-technical).  Select and read Chapter 8, 9, or 12 from Batra's book. 
It will be most helpful for your team if each team member selects a different chapter -- I think it would most fitting for the person who led Task 1 to read Chapter 8 (which focuses on trends), the person who leads Task 4 to read Chapter 12 (which attempts to build a new, prescriptive theory, relevant to Task 4), and the person who leads the presentation to read Chapter 9.

In about 1000 words, respond to Batra's chapter:
  1. What is Batra's overarching argument in the chapter?
  2. What data or logic does he use to support the argument?
  3. Are there any concepts or principles that you don't understand?
  4. How and why does his argument differ from that of the neoclassical theory of trade presented by Krugman, in my online notes on trade, trade impacts, and trade policy, and (optionally) in DRS Chapter 6?
Please bring five copies of this to class on the 16th, so you can exchange them with your team mates. 


copyright James W. Harrington, Jr.
revised 5 October 2006