Research 101 -- Evaluating and Refining Your Search

			site map \| contact us \| plug-ins

Introduction

Your Search Strategy

Credibility

Usefulness

Summary

EVALUATING WORKSHEET

Evaluating
Usefulness	<<previous pg. \| next pg.>>

Before reviewing the questions below, select one of the following sources as most useful for a research paper on the current use of primates in scientific laboratories?

A. "Monkeys in our Labs," by Scott Gottieber, a USA Today staff writer. Published in USA Today Dec 15, 1989. Includes chart, "Number of Test Primates in the US, 1975-1985."

B. Laboratory Primate Advocacy Group website. LPAG is a nonprofit organization. Website last updated in 2001. "LPAG believes that the laboratory is no place for monkeys and nonhuman great apes."

C. "Better numbers on primate research," by Constance Holden. Published by the American Association for the Advancement of Science. Appeared in Science, a scholarly publication, on March 30, 2001.

When deciding whether or not an information source is useful in the context of your research, you should consider the following issues regarding content. Click on the linked term to the right of each issue for a set of activities that will clarify your understanding of each:

Are the goals for this publication clearly stated? Is there a particular bias evident? Is the viewpoint of the author's affiliation reflected in the message or content? Does the information appear to be valid and well-researched?	Objectivity
Does this appear to be quality work? Is the information well-organized? Has the author used good grammar? Are the graphics – images, tables, charts, diagrams – appropriate and clearly presented?	Quality
How does it cover your topic? Is it comprehensive? an overview? highly detailed and narrowly-focused? Does the work update other sources?	Coverage
Does the work address your research question or meet the requirments of your assignment? Is the content appropriate for your research topic or assignment?	Relevance

<<previous pg. | next pg.>>

Know which source is best for your project.