Geography 230: Urbanization in Developing Nations
Winter 2000
Assignment #4
Presentation and Critique
of Media Representations of Issues of Urbanization in Southern Nations
Your final assignment for the quarter is a critical examination of media
representations of people and places in southern nations. You are expected
to present your critique in the form of a poster which you will present
(in 10 mins) in discussion section on March
9th, 1999. In this assignment, you will draw on the
political-economy perspective discussed in class to provide a more complex
analysis of your chosen issue than is present in the popular media.
Objectives:
-
Build an understanding of a particular place (city or region) and development
issue focusing specifically on how the place, the people and the issues
have been represented in the media
-
Develop a critical analysis of how the representations of people and places
obscure the historical and geographical relationships that have shaped
development in southern nations
-
Provide an opportunity for active/group learning and creative presentation
of ideas
NOTE: The objective of this exercise is a critical evaluation of
the representations NOT a description of them.
Your 10 minute presentation and
poster should address the following:
-
The arguments, assumptions and perspectives of the articles and sources
you are drawing from. How has the issue/place and people been represented
in the popular media? Are the people represented as clean/dirty, modern/primitive,
busy/lazy, rich/poor, healthy/sick, "exotic", feminine, child-like? Who
does the author blame for the problem? What type of development does the
author support?
-
What things are being emphasized in the physical landscape (modern buildings,
cars, pollution, high rise apartments, shanty towns or shacks, industry,
agriculture, "traditional" life or livelihoods, similarity or differences)?
What does this convey to you about the authors perspective?
-
What issues are left out of the representations (of the site you selected)
in the popular media? Think about the political, economic, and/or historical
processes that we have been discussing throughout the quarter?
KEEP THESE IDEAS IN MIND AS YOU COLLECT YOUR MATERIALS AND ORGANIZE
YOUR PRESENTATIONS
Take a look at Prof. Lawson’s web page "230 course resources"
by going to "Courses," then finding Geog 230. There are class links below
the 230 course description. Or go straight to: http://faculty.washington.edu/lawson/courses/230/230res.htm
.
Your poster should include the
following:
-
a clear theme that is represented by
the title
-
legible font type (no smaller than 14-point font)
-
photos, tables, maps, graphs and/or other figures
-
include a map that shows the geographic
location of the place you have selected
-
background information on the location
and issue (this can be presented with graphs/lists/tables, etc.)
-
comments which critically analyze media representations (e.g. bullets or
questions)
-
citations (use a smaller font) of ALL
resources (including photos, tables, etc.) which you use on the poster
Grading Criteria:
-
Synthesis: Have you shown and critiqued a variety of representations?
Have you linked the representations and your critique of them to the central
themes of the course?
-
Clarity: Are your poster and presentation clear and well-organized?
Have you effectively communicated your analysis of the representations?