=============================== CFJ 3794 ===============================
G. earned 12 coins for earning a blue ribbon for CFJ 3792.
==========================================================================
Caller: G.
Judge: Alexis
==========================================================================
History:
Called by G.: 19 Jan 2020 21:01:02
Assigned to Alexis: 25 Jan 2020 19:45:59
Judged FALSE by Alexis: 25 Jan 2020 20:05:20
==========================================================================
Caller's Arguments:
I judged CFJ 3792 five days ago (earning a blue ribbon), and then I judged
CFJ 3790 today (earning another blue ribbon).
R2602 reads:
> If a player has earned a ribbon in the past 7 days but already
> owned it e CAN once (until e earns another ribbon), by
> announcement, earn N+1 coins where N is the number of current
> players that do not own the same ribbon.
The "once (until e earns another ribbon)" is there, I believe, such that a
person can't get multiple rewards for the same judgement.
However, it also reads (unintentionally?) as a limit. If the
parenthetical
is read like this: "CAN once (until e earns another ribbon)", then the
"until" effects the "CAN", not the "once" and prevents earnings from a
previous ribbon after a new ribbon is earned. This seems like a more
natural reading to me (applying the limitation to the verb).
Caller's Evidence:
G. wrote:
> I earn 12 coins for earning a blue ribbon for CFJ 3790.
> I earn 12 coins for earning a blue ribbon for CFJ 3792.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gratuitous Arguments by Falsifian (speaking as Treasuror):
I had been assuming it worked this way, for the reason you give (i.e. you
didn't earn glitter for the CFJ 3792 blue ribbon).
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Judge Alexis's Arguments:
I judge CFJ 3794 FALSE. Per my reasoning on CFJ 3783: Thus, I find that
the the proper interpretation of Rule 2602 is that, when a player earns a
ribbon that e already owns, that player can gain income for that ribbon
one time, but e must do so prior to earning any other ribbons, and within
7 days."
==========================================================================