============================= CFJ 3463 =============================
I own a White Ribbon.
Called by Alexis: 24 Oct 2016
Assigned to aranea: 24 Nov 2016
aranea recused: 19 May 2017
Assigned to Gaelan: 19 May 2017
Judged TRUE by Gaelan: 19 May 2017
I've owned a White Ribbon before, under a different name. That name is
still listed in the Tailor's report as owning a multitude of Ribbons,
none of them White. When I re-registered recently, naturally, nobody
else knew of that, and so the Tailor's report reflects my combined
Ribbon holdings. But the report has since self-ratified.
Gratuitous Evidence by G.:
The following section of the Tailor's Report had self-ratified at the
time this CFJ was called. Alexis demonstrated that e was the same
person previously known to Agora as scshunt.
Date of this report: Thu 13 Oct 16
Date of last report: Sat 20 Aug 16
This is a list of all persons owning Ribbons, detailing which ribbons
ais523 OG MUV P WKY
Alexis C W Y
aranea ROGCBM V PLW Y
Bede M W
G. ROGCBM PLW Y
Gaelan M Y
Murphy C Y
nichdel C M Y
omd C UV KY
scshunt RO CBMU P KY
Sprocklem M W Y
the Warrigal M
I judge 3463 and 3464 as TRUE.
My reading of the rules (person can communicate logical thoughts,
player is a registered person) makes me believe that Alexis and
scshunt refer to the same player, and therefore are synonyms.
Therefore, I believe that the "ratified" Tailor's report is equivalent
R1551 states that "An internally inconsistent document generally
cannot be ratified." Therefore, the tailor's report never ratified.
Because Alexis and scshunt are the same person, they share a ribbon
switch and therefore Alexis has all ribbons from both sets.