============================== CFJ 2950 ==============================
coppro CAN cause any office to become vacant by announcement.
Called by omd: 26 Dec 2010 12:08:56 GMT
Assigned to Murphy: 10 Jan 2011 01:09:52 GMT
Judged TRUE by Murphy: 11 Jan 2011 07:50:50 GMT
This action clearly falls into R2125's "CAN be performed
while certain conditions are satisfied", as any player can do it
without objection (R1006).
[2:51 PM] starting from a blank slate, you can go two ways
[2:51 PM] for an action which is permitted in certain
circumstances by other rules
[2:51 PM] 1. coppro's rule says he CAN; R2125 is fine with it
[2:51 PM] 2. R2125 forbids it; coppro's rule doesn't apply
[2:52 PM] but... there is no way to decide which way to go
[2:52 PM] so UNDECIDABLE is appropriate
Judge Murphy's Arguments:
Rule 2125 (c) consistently uses "the rules", not "the rule". In this
case, it was triggered by Rules 1006 and 2324 collectively, causing it
to prevent making offices vacant except as allowed by "the rules" (i.e.
either Rule 1006 or Rule 2324). TRUE.