Index ← 2836 CFJ 2837 2838 → text
==============================  CFJ 2837  ==============================

    On or about 00:00 August 19, Wooble was awarded a Leadership Token
    due to the shuttle being destroyed.


Caller:                                 Tiger

Judge:                                  scshunt
Judgement:                              FALSE



Called by Tiger:                        19 Aug 2010 22:06:26 GMT
Assigned to scshunt:                    22 Aug 2010 12:15:12 GMT
Judged FALSE by scshunt:                26 Aug 2010 18:35:31 GMT


Caller's Arguments:

Uh, yeah, the shuttle is in a wormhole right now. It has been warped
and disappeared, but I think that was deemed to mean destroyed. So,
yeah, wooble probably just won. We have omd to thank for firing the
laser cannon whose recoil caused the shuttle to shoot backwards.


Caller's Evidence:

Part of R2300:

         Heavy Laser Cannon (1) - Causes 6 damage to the closest
         object with a position between 1 and 9 greater than that of
         the Shuttle. The player pushing this button may choose to
         push it harder, which increses the Charge cost by 1, the
         damage caused by 3, and causes the Shuttle to reduce its
         position by one.  Doing this when it causes the ship to have
         the same position as another object is the class-1 crime of
         Hoisting One's Own Petard.

Part of R2299

      If the Shuttle reaches the end of the journey and is warped,
      each player aboard the Shuttle is rewarded a farad. If the
      Shuttle is destroyed, the Enemy is rewarded a Leadership Token
      and can only initiate the next journey with three support
      (anyone else still only needs notice).

Part of R2297:

An object's position must be
      between 0 and the position of the second wormhole. Any object
      that finds itself outside of this area or on a wormhole is
      warped and disappears.


Gratuitous Arguments by scshunt:

R2299 says "If the Shuttle reaches the end of the journey and is
warped." The definition of end here is very confusing, however, based on
the use of "start of the journey" in the preceeding paragraph, it makes
most sense to interpret it temporally, rather than spatially. Therefore,
the statement should really be interpreted as "When the shuttle is
warped, the journey ends", which is supported by CFJ 2832. The wormhole
in which the shuttle is warped is irrelevant.


Judge scshunt's Arguments:

I judge FALSE, per my own arguments.