============================== CFJ 2577 ==============================
Sgeo has cast an unconditional vote on the Decision to adopt
Called by scshunt: 11 Jun 2009 03:16:57 GMT
Assigned to Tiger: 11 Jun 2009 04:26:29 GMT
Judged FALSE by Tiger: 11 Jun 2009 10:29:53 GMT
>>>> 6345 D 2 3.0 Pavitra Time travel
>>> FOR, unless there's reason to believe that this can hurt Agora.
> I change this vote to FOR.
Judge Tiger's Arguments:
Thi first vote seems to be a conditional vote, though one pretty hard
to validate. One could also read it as an unconditional vote followed
by the reasons for it, like "FOR, since I don't see how this could
hurt Agora" would clearly have been. This is a bit ambiguous, but when
Sgeo emself then tries to change the vote to FOR e indicates that the
first vote was indeed something other than just FOR, that is a
conditional vote. The changing of the vote failed, as one has to
retract and recast, so the original conditional vote is all e's cast.
I judge 2577 FALSE.