Index ← 2020 CFJ 2021 2022 → text
==============================  CFJ 2021  ==============================

    If an entity is both a public message and a forum, it is necessarily
    a public forum.


Caller:                                 ais523

Judge:                                  omd

Judge:                                  root

Judge:                                  Quazie
Judgement:                              FALSE



Called by ais523:                       20 Jun 2008 08:06:14 GMT
Assigned to omd:                        21 Jun 2008 05:54:11 GMT
omd recused:                            21 Jun 2008 15:10:43 GMT
Assigned to root:                       21 Jun 2008 15:57:37 GMT
root recused:                           12 Jul 2008 15:29:24 GMT
Assigned to Quazie:                     12 Jul 2008 15:36:52 GMT
Judged FALSE by Quazie:                 16 Jul 2008 18:35:53 GMT


Judge Quazie's Arguments:

R478 has two seperate definitions of Public, one a Switch state  (a)
and one directly related to messages.(b):

      Publicity is a forum switch with values Public, Discussion, and
      Foreign (default), tracked by the Registrar.

      A message is public if and only if it is sent via a public forum
      or is sent to all players and contains a clear designation of
      intent to be public.  A person "publishes" or "announces"
      something by sending a public message.

This CFJ is really asking if the public defined in (b) can be
transferred to that of (a), that is does a messages public-ness
transfer to the forum in question.

R478 also states:

      The Registrar may change the publicity of a forum without
      objection as long as:

      (a) e sends eir announcement of intent to that forum; and

      (b) if the forum is to be made public, the announcement by which
          the Registrar makes that forum public is sent to all
          existing public fora.

This regulates the fliping of the Publicity switch of a Forum, and as
a result the Publicity can not be switched to Public by having a
Forgein Forum be a Public Message.  As such, even though the entity in
question is both a public message and a Forum, it is a Public Message
and a Forgein Forum.  As a result I judge this CFJ FALSE.