Index ← 1753 CFJ 1754 1755 → text
==============================  CFJ 1754  ==============================

    message <> had the effect of resolving
    the Agoran decisions on proposals 5222 and 5223


Caller:                                 Zefram

Judge:                                  Taral
Judgement:                              FALSE



Called by Zefram:                       28 Sep 2007 20:44:37 GMT
Assigned to Taral:                      28 Sep 2007 20:48:36 GMT
Judged FALSE by Taral:                  29 Sep 2007 01:22:24 GMT


Caller's Arguments:

The message in question included a section that purported to specify
the option selected by Agora for each of those decisions:

|[This notice resolves the Agoran decisions of whether to adopt the
| following proposals.  For each decision, the options available to
| Agora are ADOPTED (*), REJECTED, and FAILED QUORUM (!).]
| 5222  O0  1    root        Consistent terminology, please
| 5223  O1  1.7  root        Trial Simplification

Since the indicator charater at the beginning of each proposal line is
space, this indicates that the option selected in each case is REJECTED.
However, the voting on both proposals was unanimously in favour, and
both met quorum (of 3, due to rubberstamp), so a correct resolution of
these decisions would indicate ADOPTED.

I pointed out the error a few hours later, so the self-ratification
instituted by R2034 does not occur.  I believe these Agoran decisions
remain unresolved, and I recommend a ruling of FALSE.


Judge Taral's Arguments:

Seems quite reasonable. I judge FALSE.