Index ← 1485 CFJ 1486 1487 → text
==============================  CFJ 1486  ==============================

    All references in public forum to "Kolja" should refer to the
    original bearer of that name, Kolja A.  This should be applicable


Caller:                                 Cainech

Judge:                                  Sir Toby

Judge:                                  OscarMeyr
Judgement:                              DISMISS



Called by Cainech:                      10 Feb 2004 22:41:58 GMT
Assigned to Sir Toby:                   14 Feb 2004 16:33:47 GMT
Sir Toby recused:                       15 Feb 2004 17:50:49 GMT
Assigned to OscarMeyr:                  15 Feb 2004 18:40:50 GMT
Dismissed by OscarMeyr:                 20 Feb 2004 02:40:24 GMT


Judge OscarMeyr's Arguments:

1486:  DISMISSED.  CFJs decide issues of fact and of the Rules,
not of intent.  Accordingly, a CFJ on whether a nickname "should" refer
to a particular entity is not relevant.  Therefore R1565(iii) applies.
The Court notes that a valid CFJ would be one that claims that a
nickname does, or does not, refer to a particular entity.


Judge OscarMeyr's Evidence:

Evidence 1:  R991

Rule 991/5 (Power=2)
Invoking Judgement

      Any person may request formal resolution of a dispute pertaining
      to this Nomic by submitting a Call for Judgement (CFJ) to the
      Clerk of the Courts.  The submission of a CFJ constitutes proof
      of the existence of such a dispute.

      A CFJ should be a single clearly-labeled Statement whose truth
      or falsity can be determined using logical reasoning, assuming
      perfect knowledge.  A CFJ may be accompanied by Arguments,
      Evidence, or other related material; the Judge is encouraged,
      but not required, to take notice of these things.

      The Clerk of the Courts shall publish the text of a CFJ, along
      with any additional material submitted by the Caller (including
      but not limited to Arguments and Evidence), no later than the
      time e announces the identity of the first Judge assigned to
      that CFJ.

Evidence 2:  R1565

Rule 1565/10 (Power=1)
Dismissal of a CFJ

      A Judgement of DISMISSED should be delivered if and only if one
      or more of the following is true:

        i) The CFJ does not contain a single clearly-identified

       ii) After a reasonable effort to obtain all relevant
           information, the Judge can neither determine the Statement
           to be true nor determine it to be false.

      iii) The Statement does not relate to a matter relevant to the

       iv) The CFJ lacks standing, as defined elsewhere.