Index ← 1226 CFJ 1227 1228 → text
==============================  CFJ 1227  ==============================

    A Low Oligarch who is entitled to cast any vote at all upon a given
    Ordinary Proposal may cast a vote of ABSTAIN upon that Proposal.


Caller:                                 Kelly

Judge:                                  Murphy
Judgement:                              TRUE



Called by Kelly:                        29 May 2000 22:04:14 GMT
Assigned to Murphy:                     31 May 2000 01:44:00 GMT
Judged TRUE by Murphy:                  03 Jun 2000 20:47:01 GMT


Judge Murphy's Arguments:

Rule 683 generally allows a vote of ABSTAIN on a Proposal.

Rule 1935 prevents multiple votes cast by an Oligarch on an Ordinary
Proposal from being ABSTAIN.  However, a Low Oligarch may cast only
one vote on an Ordinary Proposal, and is thus unaffected by this

No other Rule prevents an Oligarch's vote on an Ordinary Proposal
from being ABSTAIN, except by preventing the Oligarch from being
able to vote on it at all.


Judge Murphy's Evidence:

Rule 683/9 (Power=1)
Voting on Proposals

       A Voter authorised to cast votes on a particular Proposal may do
       so only by informing the Assessor of the vote or votes e is
       casting on that Proposal. Once cast, a vote cannot be changed or
       cancelled by the Voter which cast it, although it may be
       cancelled as other Rules require.

       A vote upon a Proposal must be one of FOR, AGAINST, or ABSTAIN
       (or an obvious synonym of one of these).  Something which is not
       one of these is not a vote upon a Proposal.

       A vote cast by an entity which does not have an Executor
       is cast at a time and in a manner specified in other Rules.

Rule 1935/0 (Power=1)
Voting by the Oligarchy

       Subject to the qualifications below, the High Oligarch must cast
       three votes, a Middle Oligarch two votes, and a Low Oligarch one
       vote, on any Ordinary Proposal on which e votes at all.

       A Player who becomes an Oligarch during the Voting Period of an
       Ordinary Proposal may not vote on that Proposal (unless the
       Proposal becomes a Democratic Proposal). An Oligarch who
       changes rank during the Voting Period of an Ordinary Proposal
       must cast as many votes as the lower rank entitles em to cast,
       if e casts any votes at all on that Proposal (again, this
       provision applies only as long the Proposal remains an Ordinary

       Multiple votes cast by an Oligarch on an Ordinary Proposal must
       be either all FOR or all AGAINST. Oligarchs may not declare
       Presence on an Ordinary Proposal.