Email the Class
Readings for Week One: Introduction
Tuesday, April 2
Today is mostly about how the class works and what it is about. We will first introduce ourselves and go over the basic elements and requirements for the class. These include
I will then give a lecture-like introduction to the subject matter we are going to cover, stressing the concepts of productivity, sustainability, and resilience, and the tradeoffs between these concepts that resource-producers and managers must deal with. This will set the basic framework for analysis of specific systems that we will be doing throughout the course. I will also take six volunteers to present answers to questions about the three basic articles on Thursday.
- Field trip procedures and ground rules
Thursday, April 4
We will have student presentations and class discussions on the three articles that six of you will bravely volunteer to report on for today. Everyone is required to post, by 7:00 a.m. today, 300-500 words on the discussion board, answering the questions for one of the readings below. These articles are difficult, so we will spend 25 minutes on each, including your presentation and discussion, and proceeding to further implications that I will help you draw out from the articles.
The first reading comes from Miguel Altieri's Agroecology. Although Altieri writes mainly about food-growing systems, the principles of energetics, diversity, scale, commercialization, and other dimensions of human-managed ecosystems apply equally to systems where some of the resources extracted are not food, and to those where food is grown in the water rather than on the land. Presenters should address the following questions:
The second reading is Simon Levin's MacArthur memorial lecture on The Problem of Scale. This is a very difficult article, so give yourself enough time to read it carefully. Its insights are particularly relevant to this class, because we will be looking directly at small-scale systems, while reading about large-scale (even planetary) systems, and we need to think carefully about how to go back and forth from one to the other, beyond simple platitudes like global and local. Presenters should address the following questions:
- What are the primary differences between a "natural" ecosystem and an agroecosystem?
- How do you think we should manage tradeoffs between short-term productivity and long-term sustainability in agroecosystems?
- Altieri is mainly talking about systems where people grow plants for food. What changes would have to be made in his analysis if we want to apply it to, for example, a forest, where people grow trees for lumber, or a beach, where people grow oysters and geoducks for food?
The final reading by Kirsten Rosselot and David T. Allen is an introduction to Life-Cycle Assessment, a method that allows us to understand the full environmental and economic impact of anything, and to understand how important both temporal and spatial scales are to understanding these impacts. You need only read to page 14 if you are in a hurry, but the presenters for today might want to read the whole thing. However much they read, the presenters should address the following questions:
- What kinds of scales do we need to consider when we analyze productivity, sustainability, and resilience in resource-production ecosystems? How are these related to each other?
- What are examples of tradeoffs at different temporal and spatial scales?
- How do we conceptualize the fit or lack of fit between the scales of the biophysical and the social components of a socio-ecosystem?
- What is meant by setting the system boundaries of an LCA? Why is it important?
- Rosselot and Allen's analysis is about manufacturing. How would we have to modify it to assess resource-production ecosystems
- LCA is a methodology worked out by environmental engineers? Does this limit its usefulness for ecologists or social scientists? Why or why not?