Geog 207 Glossary
Examination-Review Listing
(1) What is the locational significance of relatively ubiquitous materials which contribute significantly to the weight of the final product?
Name:___________________________ (Geography 207, February 9, 1999)
These kinds of broad and open-ended questions could potentially be the
basis for many dissertations which would give candidates usually more than
a year to respond. If you have 15 minutes only, and you want to reach some
depth in your answer, you need to consciously break up one or more of the
(very) general concepts (agglomeration economies, Hagerstrand's time-space
model, "location", footlooseness etc.), identify the range of component
parts or alternative perspectives (and make sure the reader gets a general
overview of the issues and is convinced of your familiarity with this
general but differentiated view of the topic, before identifying a more
limited subset which allows you to reach the desired depth. This is an
opportunity to direct your answer into a direction which suits your
background, insights and preparations! Take it, but set it up first.
It is
not advisable that you start with specific examples for something which
you really have not identified yet. A general topic does not need examples
directly, but only after specific arguments have been articulated which
respond to the way in which you have interpreted and focused the question
or topic and have broken it up into component parts. If you give examples
for the same level of generality as the topic is presented, you are
foregoing the opportunity to suggest that your answer may "depend on"
further, more fine-tuned conceptual distinctions. It is only through these
distinctions that you can present a sufficiently sophisticated response
and provide evidence for your conceptual skills and depth of
understanding.
At the end of the hour-glass approach, you want to make sure that you do
not leave the reader with a very specialized view of the issues, i.e. you
want to return from the depth selected by you back to a more general
perspective which indicates that you are aware that you just gave one
answer out of many possible answers.
In a 15-minute statement, you may not have time for more than one sentence
to do that....
All three questions cannot be answered satisfactorily
during the short time of an in-class examination without an initial brief
interpretation of the topic and some articulation of your response plans.
Use the opportunity to test your evolving conceptual skills in
Economic Geography by responding to one of these topics: (5
points). Do not hesitate to relate any of these questions (not just
#2) to your consulting area if you wish, or to use examples from other
areas for the important conceptual points and differentiations you are
making. PLEASE USE THE BACK OF THIS PAGE FOR YOUR STATEMENT!
1. On the basis of your (required) reading of Berry's chapter 9 ("Scale,
Externality, and Agglomeration...", pp.242-63 [for week 3]) and our
frequent, increasingly
differentiated discussion of "agglomeration economies", write a brief
conceptual statement on "the role of agglomeration economies (and
diseconomies) in the
evolution of settlement patterns, urban landscapes and/or locational
distributions of economic activities".
2. Give a brief explanation of how Torsten Hägerstrand's Time-Space model
might apply (with appropriate modifications or extensions) to
your anticipated consulting project(s). How might it help you to
(a) devise your own consulting strategy, OR
(b) explain to potential clients their own problems (for which they
need your help) OR
(c) explain to clients some strategy which you may want to
suggest to them to follow in order to tackle these problems.
[If you are convinced that this does not apply to your present consulting
plans, explain why. You have then the option to apply it to some other
hypothetical situation of your choosing]
3. Try to reconcile the seeming contradiction between two frequently
expressed propositions, namely
(1) that for many activities, the three
most important business factors are "location, location, location"; and
(2) that the frictions of space have been reduced for many activities
to the point of creating wide-spread "footlooseness".
BONUS (2 points maximum):