31March2008


PART I

TEXTS WHOSE AUTHORS CAN BE DATED

AUTHORS LISTED CHRONOLOGICALLY

Before the Christian Era through 4th century

[For other time frames, or an alphabetical index, click on the images above.]


1.Author Unknown (300 B.C.)

   1.Dhammasangani (Theravada) (NCat IX, 235)

1.1.1 Edited by Edward Muller. PTS 11, 1885, 1897; Bangkok 1927. Reprinted Rangoon 1939; London 1978.

1.1.2 Translated by Carolyn A.F.Rhys Davids as A Buddhist Manual of Psychological Ethics. PTSTr Series 41. London 1900, 1923, 1974; New Delhi 1975, 1996; Oxford 1993

1.1.3 Edited in Sinhalese script. Panadure: Deliwala 1911, 1914

1.1.4 Edited in Sinhalese script. Kelaniya 1916

1.1.4.1 Edited with Buddhaghosa's Atthasalini. Bangkok 1920

1.1.5 Edited by P.V.Bapat and R.D.Vadekar in Devanagari. BORI Series 2, Poona 1940, 1942.

1.1.6 Nyanaponika, Abhidhamma Studies. Researches in Buddhist Psychology. Colombo 1949

1.1.7 Nalinaksha Dutt, "The Dhammasangani", IHQ 15, 1939, 345-372

1.1.8 Translated into French by Andre Bareau. Paris 1951

1.1.9 Edited by Jagdish Kashyap. Nalanda 1960

1.1.9.5 Selections translated in Nyanaponika, Abhidhamma Studies: Researches in Buddhist Psychology. Colombo 1965

1.1.10 Bimala Churn Law, "The Dhammasangani of the Abhidhammapitaka", MB 82, 1974, 72-76

1.1.10.1 Mahesh Tiwary, "The concept of rupa in the Dhammasangani", Amala Prajna 157-163

1.1.10.2 Index to the Dhammasangani, compiled by Tetsuya Tabata, Satashi Nonome and Shoko Randa. Pali Text Society, London 1987

1.1.10.3 Edited with Buddhaghosa's Atthasalini. Four volumes. Bangkok 1988

1.1.10.4 Edited with Budhaghosa's Atthasalini, the Linathapadavannana and Anutika, by Rama Sarkar Tripathi. Varanasi 1988

1.1.10.5 Edited Thai-ratha 1989

1.1.11 Summarized by K.H.Potter. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 137-164 

1.1.12 Introduction to the Dhammasangani. Rangoon 1995

1.1.13 The Dhammasangani: Enumeration of the Ultimate Realities. Rangoon 1996

1.1.13.3 Nyanaponika Thera and Bhikkhu Bodhi, Buddhist Explanation of Consciousness and Time. Boston 1998

1.1.13.7 Edited Taipei, Taiwan 1998

1.1.14 Translated by U. Kyaw Khine. Two volumes. Delhi 1999


2. Maudgalyayana or Sariputra (300 B.C.)

        1.Dharmaskandha

2.1.1 Summarized in Takakusu, 112-115

2.1.2 Summarized in Mizuno

2.1.3 Jikido Takasaki, "Remarks on the Sanskrit fragments of the Abhidharmadharmaskandhapadasastra", JIBSt 13.1, 1965, 33-41

2.1.4 Analyzed in Watanabe 58-62

2.1.4.1 Sieglinde Dietz, Fragmente des Dharmaskandha--ein Abhidharma-text in Sanskrit aus Gilgit. Gottingen 1984. See also "Bemerkungen zum Karanaprajnaptisastra", ZDMG Supplement X, 1994, 295-306

2.1.4.2 K. Matsuda, Newly Identified Sanskrit Fragments of the Dharmaskandha in the Gilgit Manuscripts, with appendix by Hajime Sakurabe. Kyoto 1986

2.1.5 Upali Karunaratna, "Dharmaskandha", EnBud 4.4, 1989, 560-561

2.1.6 Summarized by Fred Greiner and K.H.Potter. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 179-187 

2.1.7 Summarized by Collett Cox. SarvastiBS 181=189

2.1.8 Swati Ganguly, "The moral observances for the laity as depicted in an early Abhidharma text preserved in Chinese", JDPaliUC 10, 2000, 47-51

2.1.10 Hee Sheng Shi Fashu Sim, The Pali Vibhanga and the Chinese Dharmaskandha: a Comparative Study of Two Early Abhidhamma Texts. M. Phil. Thesis, U. of Qu eensland. St. Lucia, Queensland 2004


3. Author Unknown (300 B.C.)

     1.Vibhanga

See d2.1.10

3.1.1 Edited by Carolyn A.F.Rhys Davids. PTS 55, 1904

3.1.1.1 Edited Rangoon 1912, 1939

3.1.1.2 Edited Bangkok 1926

3.1.2 Summarized in Kashyap 104-143

3.1.2.1 Edited with Buddhaghosa's Sammohavinoadani by Yagirala Pannananda. Colombo 1932

3.1.2.2 Edited and translated, with the Karmavibhangopadesa, by Sylvain Levi. Paris 1932

3.1.3 Edited by D.S.Mahathera and V. Sarman in Devanagari. Nalanda Devanagari Pali Series 30, Nalanda 1960

3.1.3.0 Edited in Pali by Jagdish Kasyap. Nalanda, Varanasi 1960

3.1.3.1 Edited with Buddhaghosa's Sammohavinoadani. Bangkok 1965

3.1.4 Translated by U Thitilla. PTSTr 39, 1969, 1995

3.1.4.5 Edited in Pali by L. Lankananda and K. Su manasara. Two volumes. Colombo 1975

3.1.5 Analyzed in Watanabe 62-63

3.1.5.1 Edited, with Mulatika and Anutika, by Brahmadeva Narayana Sarma. Varanasi 1987

3.1.5.2 Edited with Buddhaghosa's Sammohavinoadani. Thai-yattha 1989

3.1.6 Summarized by K.H.Potter. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 165-178 

3.1.7 Edited and translated by Mauro Maggi, The Khotanese Karmavibhanga. SerOR 74, Roma 1995


4.Sariputra or Mahakausthila (280 B.C.)

      1.Samgitiparyaya (Sarvastivada) (NCat I, 291)

4.1.1 Summarized in Takakusu 99-103

4.1.2 Ernst Waldschmidt, "Die Einleitung des Samgitisutra", ZDMG 105, 1955, 298-318. Reprinted in EWVCT

4.1.3 Summarized in Mizuno

4.1.4 L. de Z., "Abhidharma-Sangiti-Paryaya", EnBud 1.1, 1961, 88

4.1.5 Edited and translated in German by Valentine Stach-Rosen, "Das Sangitisutra und sein Kommentar Sangitiparyaya". Teil 1. Deutsche Akademie der Wissenschaften, Institut fur Orientforschung 65, Berlin 1968, 1-225

4.1.6 Chandrabhal Tripathi, "Samgiti-Sutra, Nipata II und Ekottaragama-Parallelen", ZSWH 191-201

4.1.7 Summarized by Christian Lindtner. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 203-216 

4.1.8 Summarized by Collett Cox. SarvastiBS 177-181


5.Author Unknown (280 B.C.)

      1.Puggalapannati (Theravada) (NCat XII, 106)

See e13.1.3

5.1.1 Edited by Richard Morris. PTS 6, 1883, 1972 2 volumes. Reprinted London 1972

5.1.1.0 Edited with Buddhaghosa's Atthakatha. Sevassinyantalaya 1906

5.1.1.1 Selections edited by Khemachari Thera. Bangkok 1926

5.1.1.2 Edited with the Dhatukatha and the Kathavatthu by Khemachari Thera (Dhammatilakacarya). Bangkok 1926

5.1.2 Summarized in Kashyap 165-180

5.1.3 Translated into German by Nyanatiloka as Das Buch der Charaktere (Breslau 1910). Section One reprinted in Einsicht 1954, 81 ff.

5.1.3.1 Edited with the Dhatukatha. Rangoon 1963

5.1.4 Edited, with Buddhaghosa's Atthakatha, by Georg Landsberg and Carolyn A.F.Rhys Davids. JPTS 1913-14, 170-254. Reprinted London 1972

5.1.5 Translated by Bimala Charan Law as Designation of Human Types. PTSTr 12, 1924

5.1.5.1 Edited with Dhatukatha. Colombo 1976

5.1.6 Edited in Tiwari

5.1.7 Om Prakash Pathak, "Vipassana and relation with Puggalapannati", VTBW 138-149

5.1.8 Summarized by K.H.Potter. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 189-202

5.1.9 Edited by Om Prakash Pathak and Veenar Gaur. Delhi 2000


6.Maudgalyayana (260 B.C.)

   1.Prajnaptisastra (Sarvastivada)

6.1.1 Summarized in Takakusu 116-118

6.1.1.1 Louis de la Vallee Poussin, Vasubandhu et Yasomitra. Troisiéme chapitre de Abhidharmakosakarika, Bhasya et Vyakhya, avec une analyse de la Lokaprajnapti et de la Karanaprajnapti de Maudgalyayana. BEM 1918, 326-350

6.1.2 Summarized in Mizuno

6.1.2.1 Sieglinde Dietz, "A brief survey on the Sanskrit fragments of the Lokaprajnaptisastra", Annual Memoirs of the Otani University Shin Buddhist Comprehensive Research Institute 7, 1989, 79-86

6.1.3 Junkishi Imanishi, "Über den Text des Prakarana" (Japanese with German summary), HiDBK 25.2, 1977, 1-37

6.1.4 Sieglinde Dietz, "Remarks on the KaraμaprajnaptiRhstra", BSPF 17-219, 87-94; also TibSt 205-212. In German as "Bemerkungen zum Karanaprajnaptisastra", ZDMG Supplement X, 1994, 295-306.

6.1.5 Summarized by Collett Cox, SarvastiBS 189-197



7.Author Unknown (250 B.C.)

   1.Patisambhidamagga

7.1.1 Edited by Arnold C. Taylor. Two volumes. PTS, London 1905-07

7.1.1.0 Edited Bangkok 1926

7.1.2 Index compiled by Mabel Hunt in JPTS 1908, 152-179

7.1.3 Edited in Burmese characters by Hsaya Hkaing. Rangoon 1917

7.1.3.00 Edited with Mahanama's commentary by C. V. Joshi. Three volumes. PTS 103-105, 1933-1947, 1979

7.1.3.0 Edited Rangoon 1959

7.1.3.01 Edited by Jagdish Kashyap. Nalanda 1960

7.1.3.1 Edited by Labugama Lankananda. Two volumes. Sri Lanka 1971

7.1.4 Translated by Nanamoli as The Path of Discrimination. PTSTr Series 43, 1982

7.1.4.1 Anonymously elucidated, with Mahanama's Saddhammappakasini, in two volumes. Krung Thep Maha Nakhon 1988

7.1.4.2 Partly edited, with Mahanama's Saddhammappaksini, by Krung Thep Maha Nakhon. 1989

7.1.4.3 Edited in four volumes. Krung Thep Maha Nakhon 1990

7.1.4.4 Edited with Mahanama's commentary. Two volumes. Thairattha 1991.

7.1.5 Summarized by James P.McDermott. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 219-264

7.1.5.5 Edited with Mahanama's Saddhammapakasini. Twovolumes. Igatapuri 1998

7.1.6 Lokaprajnapti edited with extensive exposition by K. Sankaranarayanan, Kazunotu Matsuda and Motohiro Yoritori. Bombay 2002


8.Maudgalyayana or Moggalaputra Tissa (240 B.C.)

   1.Kathavatthu (Theravada)

8.1.1 Edited, with Buddhaghosa's Atthakatha, by J.P.Minayeff. JPTS 1889: 1-199, 213-222

8.1.2 Portion translated by T.W.Rhys Davids, "Schools of Buddhist belief", JRAS 1892, 1-38

8.1.2.1 Edited in Siamese characters. Bangkok 1893-94

8.1.3 Edited by Arnold C. Taylor. Two volumes. PTS 34, 1894; 36, 1897; London 1979

8.1.3.1 Edited in Burmese script. Rangoon 1900, 1938, 1955

8.1.4 Louis de la Vallee Poussin, "Buddhist notes: 'The five points of Mahadeva and the Kathavatthu", JRAS 1909, 413-424

8.1.4.1 Edited Mantala 1922

8.1.5 Translated, with extracts from Buddhaghosa's Atthakatha by S.Z.Aung and Carolyn A.F.Rhys Davids, as Points of Controversy. PTS Series 5, 1915. Reprinted 1960, 1969, 1979, 1993

8.1.6 Dwijendra Lal Barua, "A few evidences on the age of the Kathavatthu", IHQ 7, 1931, 367-369

8.1.7 Summarized in N.N.Dutt, "Doctrines of the Mahasanghika school of Buddhism", IHQ 13, 1937, 549-580; 14, 1938, 110-120, 799-812

8.1.8 N.N.Dutt, "Doctrines of the Sammitiya school of Buddhism", IHQ 15, 1939, 90-100

8.1.9 Translated, with Buddhaghosa's Atthakatha, by Bimala Churn Law as The Debates Commentary. PTS 28, 1940, 1969, 1989

8.1.10 Carolyn A.F. Rhys Davids, "Kathavatthu--Dr. B.C.Law's translation", IC 8, 1940, 191-198

8.1.10.1 Edited by Jagdish Kashyap. Nalanda 1958, 1961

8.1.11 A.K.Warder, "The earliest Indian logic", Trudi XXV Majdunaradnogo Konressa Vostokovodov, Moscow 1963, Vol. IV, 56-68

8.1.11.1 Edited in three volumes. Sri Lanka 1967-69

8.1.11.2 Edited and translated into Sinhalese by Kodagoda Nanaloka Thera. Four volumes. Kolambha (Sri Lanksa) 1967-69,

8.1.12 Edited, with Buddhaghosa's Atthakatha, by Mahesh Tiwari. Patna 1971

8.1.13 S.N.Dube, "The date of Kathavatthu", EAW 22, 1972, 79-86

8.1.14 James P. McDermott, "The Kathavatthu kamma debates", JAOS 95, 1975, 424-433

8.1.14.1 Edited by S. Bagchi. Darbhanga 1970

8.1.15 Edited, with Buddhaghosa's Atthakatha, by N.A.Jayawickrama. London 1979

8.1.16 Shohei Ichimura, "A study of the Madhyamika method of refutation, especially of its affinity to that of Kathavatthu", JIABS 3.1, 1980, 7-15

8.1.17 Tetsuya Tabata et al., Index to the Kathavatthu. PTSText Series 174, 1982

8.1.18 James P. McDermott, "The Kathavatthu niyama debates", JIABS 12.1, 1989, 139-148

8.1.19 Shohei Ichimura, "Abhidharmika logical deadlock in Kathavatthu and Nagarjuna's Madhyamika dialectic", JIBSt 39.2, 1991, 20-24. A paper with a similar title is found in PCS 147-170

8.1.19.1 K.R.Norman, "Magadhisms in the Kathavatthu", KRNCP 2, 59-70

8.1.20 Johannes Bronkhorst, "Kathavatthu and Vijnanakaya", PCEL 57-61 

8.1.21 Summarized by James P. McDermott. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 265-304 

8.1.22 David Bastow, "Debates on time in the Kathavatthu", BudSR 13, 1996, 109-132

8.1.23 D. Saddhasena, "Kathavatthu", EnBud 6, 1999, 155-162

8.1.24 Jonardon Ganeri, "Argumentation, Dialogue and the Kathavattu", JIP 29.4, 2001, 485-493


9.Author Unknown (230 B. C.)

   1.Niddesa (Maha- and Cula-)

9.1.0 Edited by Louis de la Vallee Poussin and Edward Joseph Thomas. Three volumes. PTS 80, 83, 85. London 1916-18, 1978

9.1.0.1 Culla- edited by William Stede. Oxford 1918, 1989

9.1.0.0 Maha- edited with Upasena's Saddhammapajotika by Boruggamuva Acarya Revata Thera, revised by Mahagoda Suri Nanissara Thera. Colombo 1921, 1991

9.1.1 Sylvain Levi, "Ptolemée, le Niddesa et le Brhatkatha", EtAS 19-20.2, 1925, 1-55, 431-432

9.1.1.0 Maha- edited in Siamese characters by Kittisobhana Devamani. Two volumes. Bangkok 1926-27

9.1.1.1 B.M.Barua, "Some points concerning the Mahaniddesa", PAIOC 5.1, 1928, 603-612

9.1.1.2 Edited in Burmese script. Rangoon 1939

9.1.1.3 Edited by Lakshmi Narayana Tiwari. Patna 1959

9.1.1.4 Edited by Jagdish Kashyap. Patna 1960

9.1.1.5 Maha- edited in Sinhalese script. Colombo 1961

9.1.1.6 Cula- edited in Khmer script. Bangkok 1970

9.1.1.7 Cula- edited in Sinhalese script. Colombo 1976

9.1.2 Himamsu Bhushan Sarkar, "The date of the Pali Niddesa and its implications for the history of South-east Asia", KPJCV 207-229

9.1.3 Summarized by Grace G. Burford. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 305-316 

9.1.4 L.S. Cousins (cp.), Index to the Mahaniddesa. Oxford 1995

9.1.5 Cula- edited, with Upasena's Saddhammppajotika and the Nettippakarana with Dhammapalathera's commentary. Igatapuri 1998

9.1.6 Maha- edited with Saddhammpakasini and Upasena's Saddhammappajotika. Igatapuri 1998

9.1.7 Edited Taipei, Taiwan 2000

9.1.8 Maha- edited with Atthakatha and Saddhammapajjatika by Rabindra Panth and Vijaya Kumara Sarma. Nalanda 2002


10.Author Unknown (225 B.C.)

     1.Sariputrabhidharmasastra

10.1.1 Summarized in Takakusu 144

10.1.2 Andre Bareau, "Récherches sur l'Abhidharma de Sariputra", CIDO 21, 1947, 187-188

10.1.3 Andre Bareau, "Les origines du Sariputrabhidharmasastra", LM 68, 1950, 69-95

10.1.4 Analyzed in Watanabe 63-64

10.1.5 Summarized by Shingyo Yoshimoto. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 317-325 


11.Author Unknown (200 B.C.)

     1.Yamaka

11.1.0 Edited in Thai script. Phranakhon 1893-94, 1982, 1988

11.1.1 Parts 6-10 edited in Burmese characters by Hsaya Lingayama. Mandalay 1905

11.1.2 Edited, with Buddhaghosa's Atthakatha, by Carolyn A.F. Rhys Davids. JPTS 1910-1912, 51-107. Complete in two volumes, PTS 69, 1911; 73, 1913. Reprinted 1987, 1995

11.1.2.1 Edited by Khemachari Dhammatilokacharya. Two volumes. Bangkok 1927

11.1.2.2 Edited in Burmese script. Three volumes. Rangoon 1939, 1943, 1955, 1982

11.1.3 Outlined with some selections in Kashyap 177-195

11.1.3.1 Edited by Jagdish Kashyap. Three volumes. Nalanda 1961

11.1.4 Edited by D.S.Mahathera and V. Sarma, NDPS 33-35, 1961

11.1.5 Edited, with Buddhaghosa's Atthakatha, by Mahesh Tiwari. Patna 1972

11.1.5.5 Edited in Pali and Sinhalese by M. Vimalakirti and K. Sumanasara. Two volumes. Colombo 1988

11.1.6 Summarized by Karen C. Lang. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 327-336 

11.1.7 Edited in three volumes. Igatapuri 1998


12.Author Unknown (200 B.C.)

     1.Patthana

See y18.1.4

12.1.1 Paccayavibhangavara and Kusalatika edited in Burmese characters by Hsaya Sudhamma. Mandalay 1904

12.1.2 Duka section edited by Carolyn A.F. Rhys Davids. PTS 1906

12.1.2.1 Edited in Burmese characters. Rangoon 1911, 1918, 1926-27, 1939, 1978

12.1.3 Edited, with Buddhaghosa's Atthakatha, by Carolyn A.F.Rhys Davids. Three volumes. PTS 90, 92, 94 (1921-1923)

12.1.4 Summarized in Kashyap 196-217

12.1.4.1 Edited in six volumes by Jagdish Kashyap. Nalanda 1961

12.1.5 Edited in Sinhalese characters by Nanavimala Thera. Four volumes. Colombo 1954-55

12.1.5.1 U. Visuddha, An Approach to Patthana (Buddhist Philosophy of Relations). Rangoon 1956

12.1.5.2 Selections edited in Thai script. Bangkok 1965

12.1.6 Edited by D.S.Mahathera and V. Sarman. NDPS 36-41, 1961

12.1.7 Translated by U Narada as Conditional Relations. Section 1, PTSTr 37, 1969. Sections 2-5, PTSTr 42, 1981. Reprinted 1981, 1992

12.1.8 U Narada, Guide to Conditional Relations. Part I, being a Guide to pp. 1-12 of Conditional Relations (Patthana). PTS 1979

12.1.8.1 L. S. Cousins, "The Patthana and the development of Theravada Abhidharma", JPTS 9, 1987, 22-46

12.1.8.2 Edited in Sinhalese script. Three volumes. Colombo 1988-89; Pkunuvita 1997

12.1.9 Summarized by K.H.Potter. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 337-344

12.1.10 Edited in five volumes. Igatapuri 1998


13.Author Unknown (180 B.C.)

     1.Dhatukatha

See e5.1.1.2. e5.1:3.1,5.1

13.1.1 Edited, with Buddhaghosa's Atthakatha, by Edmund Rowland Jayatilleke Gunaratna. PTS London 1892

13.1.2 Summarized in Kashyap 144-164

13.1.3 Edited, with Puggalapannati, by D.S.Mahathera and V. Sarman in NDPS 31, 1960

13.1.4 Edited by U Narada. PTS 1962

13.1.5 Translated by U Narada and Thein Nyun as Discourse on Elements. PTSTr 34, London 1962, 1977, 1999

13.1.6 Edited in Tiwari

13.1.7 Senanath Wijesundara, "Dhatukatha", EnBud 4.4, 1989, 575

13.1.7.1 Edited by Sitamsu Bikasa Barua in Bengali script. Cattagrama 1990

13.1.8 Summarized by K.H.Potter. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 359-365 


14.Vasumitra (180 B.C.)

     1.Dhatukaya

14.1.1 Summarized in Mizuno

14.1.2 Upali Karunaratne, "Dhatukaya", EnBud 4.4, 1989, 576

14.1.3 Summarized by Robert E. Buswell, Jr. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 345-358 

14.1.3.1 Edited in Korean characters. Seoul 1994

14.1.4 Hsuang-tsang's Chinese translation translated by Swati Ganguli in Treatise on Groups of Elements. Delhi 1994

14.1.5 Summarized by Collett Cox, SarvastiBS 206-212


15.Vasumitra (170 B.C.)

     1.Prakaranapada (Sarvastivada) (NCat l, 291)

15.1.1 Summarized in Takakusu 104-106

15.1.2 Summarized in Mizuno

15.1.3 Summarized by Christian Lindtner and K.H.Potter. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 375-379 

15.1.4 Summarized by Collett Cox, SarvastiBS 212-221

15.1.5 Lambert Schmithausen, "Zwei fragmente aus dem Prakarana", Vividha 481-492

15.1.6 Lambert Schmithausen, "Ein weiteres Fragment aus dem Prakarana: SHT VII 1697", WZKSOA 46, 2002, 51-104


16.Devasarman (170 B.C.)

     1.Vijnanakaya (NCat I, 291)

See a8.1.20.

16.1.1 Louis de la Vallee Poussin, "La controverse du temps et du pudgala dans le Vijnanakaya", EtAs 343-376. Reprinted ETB 79-112

16.1.2 Summarized by Kogen Mizuno. StudPB 29-39

16.1.3 David Bastow, "The first argument for Sarvastivada", AsPOxford 5.1, 1995, 109-126

16.1.4 Sumarized by Collett Cox, SarvastiBS 197-205


17.Author Unknown (150 B.C.)

        1.Petakopadesa

17.1.1 Rudolf Fuchs, Specimen des Petakopadesa .Chapter I. Inaugrual-Dissertation, Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität zu Berlin. Halle 1908

17.1.2 Translated into German by Nyanatiloka. Breslau 1910. Section one reprinted in Einsicht 1954, pp. 181 ff.

17.1.3 Edited, with Buddhaghosa's Atthakatha, by Georg Landsberg and C.A.F.Rhys Davids. JPTS 1913-1914, 170-254

17.1.4 Translated by Bimala Charan Law as Designation of Human Types. PTSTr 12, 1924

17.1.5 Edited by Arabinda Barua. PTS 88, 1949, 1988

17.1.6 Edited in Burmese script. Rangoon 1956

17.1.7 Translated by Nanamoli as The Pitaka-Disclosures (Petakopadesa). PTS 35, 1964, 1979

17.1.8 Edited in Thai script. Bangkok 1970, 1980

17.1.8.5 Stefano Zacchetti, "Some remarks on the petaka passages of Da zhidu lun and their relation to the Pali Petakopadesa", ARIRSU 13, 2001, 67-86333

17.1.9 Stefan Zacchetti, "An early Chinese translation corresponding to Chapter 6 of the Petakopadesa: An Shigao's Yin chi rujina (T.1603) and its Indian original: a preliminary study", BSOAS 65.1, 2002, 74-98


18.Author Unknown (150 B.C.)

        1.Nettippakarana

See e9.1.5

18.1.1 Edited, with extracts from Dhammapala's commentary, by E. Hardy. PTS 50, 1902, 1961

18.1.2 Edited, with Dhammapala's commentary, by Widurupola Piyatissa (Thera). Colombo 1921

18.1.3 Edited in Sinhalese script by W.M.N.E. Perera. Talarambe, Ceylon 1923

18.1.4 Carolyn A.F.Rhys Davids, "The Nettipakarana an earlier book than the Patthana (Maha-Pakarana)", JRAS 1925, 111-113

18.1.5 Translated by Nanamoli as The Guide. PTS 33, 1962

18.1.6 W. Piyananda Thera, "The Netti-pakarana and the logic of interpretation", MB 85, 1977, 190-195

18.1.9 Edited in Sinhalese script. Colombo 1980

18.1.10 George D. Bond, "The Netti-pakarana - a Theravada method of interpretation", BSWR 16-28

18.1.11 Summarized by George D. Bond. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 403-416 

18.1.12 Senmyo Naniwa, "A study on the Nettipakarana analysis of Hara (2)", BS 27, 1998, 187-206

18.1.13 Edited with Dhammapada's Tika. Igatapuri 1998

18.1.14 Ken'ichi Furuyama, "'Netti' and the 'Nettipakarana'", JIBSt 54.3, 2006, 163-164

18.1.15 Peter Jackson, "The canonicity of the Netti and other works", JPTS 28, 2006, 61-62


18A.Author Unknown (50 B.C.?)

        1.Satparamita

18A.1 See EnIndPh 8, 1999, 79


19.Katyayaniputra (25 B.C.)

     1. Jnanaprasthana (Sarvastivada) (NCat I, 290; III, 332; VII, 330)

19.1.1 Summarized in Takakusu 86-98

19.1.2 Partly translated into French by Louis de la Vallee Poussin in DA I and II

19.1.3 Anukul Chandra Banerjee, "The Jnanaprasthanasutra", MB 63, 1955, 295-297

19.1.4 Partly rendered into Sanskrit from Chinese by Shanti Bhiksu Shastri. VBS 25, 1955

19.1.5 Retranslated from Chinese to Sanskrit from Hsuan-tsang's version by Santibhiksu Sastri. VBA 1, 1955

19.1.6 Fragment edited and translated into French by Paul Demieville, "Un fragment Sanskrit de l'Abhidharma des Sarvastivadin", JA 249, 1961, 461-476

19.1.7 Summarized in Mizuno

19.1.8 Leon N. Hurvitz, "Path to salvation in the Jnanaprasthana", SIAAC 5, 1977, 77-102

19.1.9 Summarized by Edwin Gerow and K.H.Potter. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 417-449 

19.1.10 Summarized by Collett Cox, SarvastiBS 221-229

19.1.11 Upali Karunaratne, "Jnanaprasthana", EnBud 6, 1996, 60

19.1.12 Lambert Schmithausen, "Das Jnanaprasthana: Fragment SHT 823", BVSK 559-569

19.1.15 Charles Hallisey, "Katyayaniputra", EnBuddhism 440-442


20.Dharmasri (0 A.D.) or (Bhadanta) Dharmatrata (150 A.D.) (NCat IX, 246-247)

     1.Abhidharmahrdaya

20.1.1 P. Pelliot, "Les stances d'introduction de l'Abhidharmasastra de Dharmatrata", JA 217, 1930, 267-273

20.1.2 T. Rajapatirane, "Abhidharmahrdayasastra", EnBud 1.1, 1961, 57

20.1.3 Charles Willemen, The Essence of Metaphysics. Abhidharmahrdaya. Bruxelles 1975

20.1.3.5 Translated into French by I. Armelin. Paris 1978

20.1.4 Leon Hurvitz, "Dharmasri on the sixteen degrees of comprehension", JIABS 2.2, 1979, 7-30

20.1.4.0 W. R. Ryose, "The position of the Abhidharmahrdaya in the historical development of Sarvastivada thought", Abhidhamma Research Institute No. 5. Kyoto 1986, 1-16

20.1.4.1 Wataru S. Ryose, A Study of the Abhidharmahrdaya: The Historical Development of the Concept of Karma in the Sarvastivada Thought. Ph.D.Thesis, University of Wisconsin 1987

20.1.5 Summarized by Charles Willemen. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 451-470 

20.1.6 Summarized by Bart Dessein, SarvastiBS 255-269

20.1.8 Lalit 'Shravak', "Misrakabhidharmahrdayasutra–fusion of bahirdesaka and Kasmira Abhidharma traditions", IIJBS 2, 2001, 71-84


21.Author Unknown (25 A.D.)

     1. Milindapanha

21.1.1 Edited by V. Trenckner in Pali Miscellany. London 1879

21.1.2 Edited by V. Trenckner, The Milindapanha. London 1880, 1928, 1962, 1986

21.1.3 Richard Morris, "Buddhaghosa and the Milindapanha", IA 10, 1881, 153 

21.1.4 Partly translated into French by Lewis de Sylva as Le Bonheur du Nirvana. RHR 11, 1885, 336-352

21.1.5 Translated by T.W. Rhys Davids as The Questions of King Milinda. Two volumes. SBE 35, 1890; 36, 1894. Reprinted New York 1963; Delhi 1965, 1969, 1982; London 1925, 1962; Ann Arbor 1987; New Delhi 1963, 1990; Varanasi 1993

21.1.6 T.W.Rhys Davids, "Nagasena", JRAS 1890, 475-478

21.1.7 Eduoard Specht, "Deux traductions chinoises du Milindapanha", CIDO 9.1, 1892, 518-529

21.1.8 Sylvain Levi, "Un nouveau document sur le Milindapanha", Comptes rendus de l'academie des inscriptions et belles-lettres, 4th series 21, 1893, 232-237

21.1.9 Edited in Singhalese characters by M.J.Rodrigo. Colombo 1896

21.1.10 Edited in Singhalese characters by Anomadassi. Colombo 1896

21.1.11 Partly translated by Henry C. Warren in Buddhism in Translations. Cambridge, Mass. 1896

21.1.12 J. Takakusu, "Chinese translations of the Milinda Panha", JRAS 1896, 1-22

21.1.12.1 Edited by William J. Gedney in Thai characters. Rangoon 1900, 1920, 1929, 1953

21.1.13 Translated into German by F. Otto Schrader as Die Frage des Königs Menandros. Berlin 1905, 1907

21.1.14 Partly translated into German by Ernst Windisch in Buddha's Geburt und die Lehre von der Seelenwanderung. Leipzig 1908

21.1.15 V. Trenckner, "Critical and philological notes to the first chapter (bahirakatha) of the Milindapanha" (revised and edited by Dines Andersen). JPTS 1908

21.1.16 Edited in Bengali characters by Vidhusekhara Bhattacharya. Calcutta 1909

21.1.17 Partly translated into German by Karl Seidenstucker in Zeitschrift fur Buddhismus 1, 1913, 1-7

21.1.17.1 Translated by Edward Joseph Thomas in Buddhist Scriptures. New York 1913

21.1.18 Edited in Burmese characters by Hsaya Hbe. Rangoon 1915, 1916

21.1.19 Partly edited in Burmese by Pe Maung Tin. Rangoon 1915

21.1.20 T.W.Rhys Davids, "Milinda", ERE 8, 1915, 1926: 631-633

21.1.20.1 Paul Pelliot, Les noms propres dans les traductions chinoises des Milindapanha. Paris 1915

21.1.21 Edited by U Maung Kale in Burmese characters. Rangoon 1917.

21.1.22 Translated into German by Nyanatiloka as Die Fragen des Milinda. Leipzig 1919, 1924. Sections of Chapter Two reprinted in ZBVG 2, 1920, 73-111

21.1.23 Edited by Hsaya Hba Kyaw in Burmese. Rangoon 1919

21.1.24 Portions translated by E.W.Burlingame, Buddhist Parables translated from the Original Pali. New Haven 1922

21.1.24.1 Edited in Thai characters. Bangkok 1922, 1923, 1924, 1825, 1933, 1953, 1970, 1978, 1984, 1985, 1989

21.1.25 Translated into French by Louis Finot as Les questions du Milinda (Milindapanha). Paris 1923, 1992

21.1.26 Translated into Italian from an English translation by G. Cagnola as Dialoghi des Re Milinda. Milano 1923

21.1.27 Paul Demieville, "Les versions chinoises du Milindapanha", BEFEO 24, 1924, 1-258

21.1.28 Arthur Pfungst, Die Fragen des Königs Milinda. In his Gesammelte Werke Volume 2, Frankfurt-am-Main 1926, 105-120.

21.1.28.1 Edited in Khmer script. Phnom Phen 1929, 1961, 1963, 1992

21.1.29 Carolyn A.F. Rhys Davids, The Milinda Questions. London 1930

21.1.30 F. Otto Schrader, "Two unexplained names in the Milindapanha", JRAS 1939, 606-608

21.1.31 Edited by R. D. Vadekar. Devanagari Pali Text Series 7, Bombay 1940

21.1.32 Siegfried Behrsing, "Beitrage zu einer Milindapanha Bibliographie", BSOAS 7.2, 1943, 335-345; 7.3, 1943, 517-539

21.1.33 K. de Vreese, Het Milinhapanha. Leiden 1948

21.1.33.1 Edited in Thai characters. Khon Kaen 1950

21.1.33.2 Edited in Burmese characters by Thera Gundankara. Rangoon 1952

21.1.34 Shashi Bhusan Dasgupta, "Nagasena's popular exposition of Buddhist doctrines", BRMIC 4, 1953, 188-192

21.1.35 Kyosho Hayashima, "Dialogue relation to atman and anatman in Milindapanha", Tokyo University Asian Studies 1, 1961, 7-14

21.1.36 Arthur L. Herman, "Ethical theory in Theravada Buddhism", JBRS 47, 1961, 170-187

21.1.37 A.A.G.Bennett, "Milindapanha--the Milinda inquiry", MB 71, 1963, 188-198

21.1.38 Translated as Milinda's Questions by Isaline Blew Horner. Two volumes. Sacred Books of the Buddhists 22-23, London 1963-64, 1969, 1990

21.1.39 Thich Minh Chan, Milindapanha and Nagasenabhiksusutra. A Comparative Study &#&#through Pali and Chinese Sources. Calcutta 1964

21.1.40 Edited in Pali and Sanskrit by Jagannatha Pathak. Varanasi 1964

21.1.41 D. M. Derrett, "Greece and India, the Milindapanha, the Alexander romance and the Gospels", Zeitschrift fur Religions und Geistes-Geschichte 19.1, 1967, 33-64

21.1.41.1 Edited in Burmese characters. Rangoon 1968, 1982, 1986, 1996

21.1.41.2 Edited in Pali and Sinhalese. 1970

21.1.41.3 Edited by Nu'u Dinh Cao and translated into Burmese by Na-Tien Ty Khao. Saigon 1970

21.1.41.4 Edited in Vietnamese. Gagneus (France) 1971, 1994, 1996; Saigon 1971

21.1.42 James P. McDermott, "Nibbana as a reward for kamma", JAOS 93, 1973, 344-347

21.1.42.1 Selections edited in Thai. Krung Thep Maha Nekhan 1973

21.1.43 Rabindra Nath Basu, "Anattavada in the Milindapanha", in BandJ 178-180

21.1.43.1 C. Robert Linne, The Historical Context of the Milindapanha: Graeco-Buddhist Contact in the Second Century B.C. Ph.D.Thesis, Northwestern University 1976; Ann Arbor 1981

21.1.44 James P. McDermott, "Karma in the Milindapanha", JAOS 97, 1977, 460-468

21.1.44.1 Osamu Yoshida, The Problem of Self in the Milindapanha with the study of the text and the Agamas. Ph.D.Dissertation, Columbia University 1977

21.1.45 Rabindra Nath Basu, A Critical Study of the Milindapanha. A Critique of Buddhist Philosophy. Calcutta 1978

21.1.46 Edited by Dvarikadas Sastri. Varanasi 1979, 1998

21.1.46.1 Translated into Korean by Kyong-su So. Seoul 1978

21.1.47 T. Pobozniak, "The problem of dream in Milindapanha", LSFV 675-678

21.1.48 N. Malle, "The questions of King Milinda, an example of philosophical analysis", with comments by P.K.Mohapatra. ASBP 63-69

21.1.48.0 Translated into German by Nyanaponika Thera as Die Fragen des konigs Milinda zweigesprache zwischen einen Griechenkonig und einem buddhistischen Monch. Interlaken 1985

21.1.48.1 Arvind Sharma, "The relation between disease and karma in the Milindapanha", Amala Prajna 139-144

21.1.48.05 Oskar von Hinuber, "The oldest dated manuscript of the Milindapanha", JPST 11, 1987, 111-118

21.1.48.06 Oskar von Hinuber, "An additional note on the oldest dated manuscript of the Milindapanha", JPTS 12, 1988, 173-174

21.1.48.07 Michael Fuss, "Milindapanha, ein Kompendium fur ein Dialog des Friedens", Studia Missionalia 38, 1989, 283-313

21.1.48.08 Edited in Rusian by A.V.Paribok. Moscow 1989

21.1.48.09 Sukukmar Sengupta, "Medical data in the Milindapanha", BMBCV 111-117

21.1.49 Angraj Chaudhary, "The problem of karma and rebirth as discussed in the Milinda-panha", JDBSDU 14, 1990, 60-67

21.1.49.1 Balakrishna Govind Goikhale, "The image-world of the Milinda Panha", IJBS 2.1, 1990, 1-12

21.1.50 Toshiichi Enda, "Some significant epithets and qualities of the Buddha as found in the Milindapanha", Ananda 160-171

21.1.50.5 Abridged in Bhikkhu Pesala, The Debate of King Milinda. Delhi 1991, 1993

21.1.50.6 Edited by Dvarikadas Sastri. Varanasi 1990

21.1.51 Summarized by K.H.Potter. EnIndPh 7, 1994, 471-488 

21.1.52 Edited Nolot, Entretiens de Milinda et Nagasena.Paris 1995

21.1.52.5 Fernando Tola and Carmen Dragonetti, "Milindapanha (fragmento): las prequentas de Milinda", REB 9, 1995, 130-144

21.1.53 Edited in Thai characters. Kurng Thep 1997

21.1.54 Sodo Mori, 'The Milindapanha and the Pali Attkatha literature", ITaur 23-24, 1998-1999, 291-312

21.1.57 W. Pachow, "An assessment of the highlights in the Milindapanha", CHBJ 13.2, 2000, 1-28

21.1.60 Takateru Hazuki, "A study of the original text of the Milindapanha", Tohogaku 105, 2003, (summary) 13

21.1.63 Edward Ray Falls, Buddhist Mereological Analysis in the Milindapanha, Vasubandhu's 20 Verses and Santideva's Bodhicaryavatara. M. A. Thesis. U. of Wisconsin 2005


22.Jaimini (25 A.D.) (NCat VII, 308)

     1.Mimamsasutras

See a220.1.20. i29.1.38

22.1.1 Book I.1 edited and translated by J.R.Ballantyne. Allahabad 1851

22.1.2 Edited, with Sabara's Bhasya, by Mahesacandra Nyayaratna. Two volumes. BI 45, 1863-1877, 1889

22.1.3 Edited, with Vidyaranya's (=Madhava's) Nyayamalavistara, by Theodore Goldstucker (London 1865-67), and completed by E.B.Cowell, London 1878. Reprinted Osnabruck 1970

22.1.4 Edited, with Vidyaranya's Nyayamalavistara, by Satyavrata Samasramin. THC 1-3, 1867-70: 1, 9, 17, 25, 31, 41

22.1.5 Edited with Gaga Bhatta's Bhattacintamani. Pan 5, 1870-71 - 8, 1873-74

22.1.6 Partially edited, with parts of Kumarila's Slokavarttika and Tantravarttika. Pan n.s. 3, 1878-79 - n.s.4, 1882

22.1.7 Edited, with Vidyaranya's Nyayamalavistara, in Telugu characters. Vizagapatam 1881

22.1.8 Edited, with Kumarila's Tantravarttika, by Gangadhara Sastri. BenSS 3, 1882-1903

22.1.9 Edited, with Vidyaranya's Nyayamalavistara, by Jivananda Vidyasagara. Calcutta 1883, 1889, 1983

22.1.10 Edited, with Sabara's Bhasya, by Jivananda Vidyasagara. Two volumes. Calcutta 1883

22.1.11 Tarkapada (I.1-32) edited, with Parthasarathi's Sastradipika, by Rama Misra Sastri. Pan n.s. 7, 1885 - 13, 1891. Reprinted Banaras 1891

22.1.12 Samkarsanakanda edited, with Khandadeva's Bhattadipika, by Rama Misra Sastri. Pan n.s. 14, 1892: 1-32. 15, 1893: 33-127

22.1.13 Edited, with Vidyaranya's Nyayamalavistara, by Sivadatta Pandita. ASS 24, 1892, 1916

22.1.14 Edited, with Ramesvara's Subodhini, by Nityananda Panta. Pan n.s. 17, 1895 - 21, 1899. Reprinted 1899

22.1.15 Edited, with Kumarila's Slokavarttika and Parthasarathi Misra's Nyayaratnakara, by Rama Sastri. ChSS 11, 1898-1899

22.1.16 Tarkapada (I.1-4) translated, with Kumarila's Slokavarttika and excerpts from Parthasarathi Misra's Nyayaratnakara and Sucarita Misra's Kasika, by Ganganatha Jha. BI 146, 1900-1909. Portion reprinted in Source Book 498-505

22.1.17 Edited, with Khandadeva's Bhattadipika, by Candrakanta Tarkalamkara and Pramathanatha Tarkabhusana. BI 143, 1899-1912

22.1.18 Edited, with Gaga Bhatta's Bhattacintamani, by Ramakrsna Shastri Patavardhana. ChSS 6, 1900, 1933

22.1.19.1 Book I.3-7 edited, with Khandadeva's Mimamsakaustubha, by P.B.Ananthachariar. Three volumes. SMS 14, 22, 42: 1902-1911

22.1.20 Partly translated, with Kumarila's Tantravarttika, by Ganganatha Jha. BI 161, 1903-1924

22.1.21 Partly edited, with Kumarila's Tuptika, by Gangadhara Sastri. BenSS 16, 1903-04

22.1.22 Edited, with Khandadeva's Bhattadipika, by A. Mahadeva Sastri and L. Srinivasacarya. MOLP 35, 1907; 40, 1911; 46, 1914; 49, 1916. Four volumes. Reprinted 1986

22.1.23 Edited, with Parthasarathi Misra's Sastradipika and editor's Prakasa thereon, by Sudarsanacarya Panjabi. Banaras 1907

22.1.24 Partially edited, with Vasudeva Diksita's Kutuhalavrtti, by S. Kuppuswami Sastri. SVVSS 1, 1907

22.1.25 Partly translated, with part of Sabara's Bhasya and notes from Kumarila's Slokavarttika, by George Thibaut. IT 2, 1910

22.1.26 Edited, with Sabara's Bhasya, by Ratna Gopala Bhatta. KSS 42, 1910

22.1.27 Translated, with a summary of Prabhakara's Brhati, by Ganganatha Jha. IT 2, 1910: 121-164, 219-402. 3, 1911: 1-89. Reprinted as The Prabhakara School of Mimamsa. Allahabad 1911; Delhi 1978

22.1.28 Edited, with Parthasarathi Misra's Sastradipika, Somanatha's Mayukhamalika, Ramakrsna's Yuktisnehaprapurani, and Vidyaranya's Nyayamalavistara, by Dharmadatta (Baccha) Jha. Bombay 1915

22.1.29 Edited, with Khandadeva's Bhattadipika and editor's Bhattakalpataru, by Ramasubrahmanya Sastri. Tanjore 1915

22.1.30 Edited, with Vidyaranya's Nyayamalavistara. Bombay 1915

22.1.31 Tarkapada section edited, with Parthasarathi Misra's Sastradipika and Ramakrsna's Yuktisnehaprapurani, by L.S.Dravida. ChSS 43, 1916

22.1.32 Book One edited, with Vidyaranya's Nyayamalavistara, by Satyapati Vidyabhusana. Calcutta 1916

22.1.33 Books 1-3 edited and translated by Ganganatha Jha. SBH 10, 1911-1916, 1974

22.1.34 Book One edited, with Khandadeva's Bhattadipika and Sambhubhatta's Prabhavali, by N.S.Anantakrishna Sastri and V.L.S.Pansikar. Bombay 1921

22.1.35 K.A.Nilakantha Sastri, "Jaimini and Badarayana", IA 50, 1921, 167

22.1.36 Book 1.1-4 edited and translated by Mohan Lal Sandal. SBH 27, 1923; 28, 1925; New York 1974, 1979

22.1.37 Edited, with Kumarila's Slokavarttika and Sucarita Misra's Kasika, by K.Sambasiva Sastri and V.A.Ramaswami Sastri. Three volumes. TSS 90, 99, 150: 1926-1943

22.1.38 Edited, with Khandadeva's Mimamsakaustubha, by A. Chinnaswami Sastri and Pattabhirama Sastri. ChSS 58, 1924-1933, 1985, 1991

22.1.39 Shripad Krishna Belvalkar, "Jaimini's Sariraka-sutra", AIK 163-170

22.1.40 Book I.2.1 (Arthavadadhikarana) edited, with Murari Misra's Tripadinitinayana, by S.K.Ramanatha Sastri. JOR 2, 1928, 266-278

22.1.41 Edited, with Kumarila's Tantravarttika and Tuptika, Vaidyanatha's Prabha and Murari Misra's Angatvanirukti, by Subha Sastri. Five volumes. ASS 97, 1929-33

22.1.42 Partly edited, with Prabhakara's Brhati and Salikanatha Misra's Rjuvimalapancika, by A. Chinnasvami Sastri. ChSS 69, 1929-33

22.1.43 Mangal Deva, "Metrical bases of the Mimamsa Sutras of Jaimini", PAIOC 5, 1930, 842-854

22.1.44 Partly edited, with Kumarila's Tuptika and Parthasarathi Misra's Tantraratna thereon, by Ganganatha Jha and Gopal Sastri Nene. Four volumes. POWSBT 31: 1930, 1933, 1963. Volume Four edited by Pattabhirama Sastri, 1972

22.1.45 Book 1.2.4 (Mantradhikarana) edited, with Murari Misra's Tripadinitinayana, by S.K.Ramanatha Sastri. JOR 5, 1931. Supplement 5 pp.

22.1.46 Translated, with Sabara's Bhasya, by Ganganatha Jha. GOS 66, 1933; 70, 1934; 73, 1936. Reprinted 1973-74. Three volumes. Portions reprinted in Source Book, 487-498, also in SourceBAP 82-91

22.1.47 V.A.Ramaswami Sastri, "The Samkarsa-kanda--a genuine supplement to the Purvamimamsa Sastra", IHQ 9, 1933, 290-299

22.1.48 Book I.3.10 edited, with Kumarila's Tantravarttika, Govindamuni's Bhasya, Parthasarathi Misra's Sastradipika, Annambhatta's Subodhini and Vasudeva Diksita's Kutuhalavrtti. COJ 2, 1934-35, 12-134

22.1.49 Edited, with Khandadeva's Bhattadipika and Vanchesvara Yajvan's Cintamani, by V. Subrahmanya Sastri. Madras 1934

22.1.50 Edited, with Vidyaranya's Nyayamalavistara, by K.A.Ramanatha Sastri and Pattabhirama Sastri. KSS 126, 1937

22.1.51 Edited, with Bhavanatha Misra's Nayaviveka and Ravideva's Vivekatattva, by S.K.Ramanatha Sastri. MUSS 12, 1937

22.1.52 Edited, with Parthasarathi Misra's Sastradipika and Appayya Diksita's Mayukhavali, by P.P.Subrahmanya Sastri. JSG 1-5 (1939-1944). Reprinted as SSGS 3 or MGOS 8

22.1.53 G.V.Devasthali, "On the probable date of Jaimini and his sutras", ABORI 21, 1939-40, 63-72

22.1.54 Book I.1-4 edited, with Kumarila's Slokavarttika through the sphota section and Umbeka's commentary thereon, by S.K.Ramanatha Sastri. MUSS 13, 1940. Second revised edition by K. Kunjunni Raja and R. Thangaswamy, 1971

22.1.55 Book I.1-4 (Tarkapada) section translated, with Parthasarathi Misra's Sastradipika, by D. Venkataramaiah. GOS 89, 1940

22.1.56 Ganganatha Jha, Purva-Mimamsa in its Sources. Banaras 1942

22.1.57 G.V.Devasthali, "Views of Jaimini and Sabara on the different classes of words", ABORI 30, 1950, 89-130

22.1.58 Edited by Kevalananda Sarasvati. Bombay 1948

22.1.59 D.T.Tatacarya, "Rgveda and the Purvottaramimamsa methods of interpretation", JSVRI 9, 1948: 25-40, 63-80

22.1.60 D.V.Garga, "Jaimini-Sabara and the science of grammar", ABORI 30, 1950, 254-262

22.1.61 V.A.Ramaswami Sastri, "Further light on Sankarsakanda", SB 102-105

22.1.62 Book One edited, with Sucarita Misra's Kasika and Rsiputra Paramesvara's Jaiminiyasutrarthasamgraha thereon, by P.K.Narayana Pillai. TSS 156, 1951

22.1.63 G.H.Bhatt, "Vallabhacarya's text of the Jaimini Sutras II.1", JOI 2, 1952, 68-70

22.1.64 Nanikram Vasanmal Thadani, The Mimamsa: Secret of the Sacred Books of the Hindus. Delhi 1952

22.1.65 Edited, with Khandadeva's Bhattadipika and Sambhubhatta's Prabhavali, by S.Subrahmanya Sastri. MUSS 19, 1952, 1957

22.1.66 B. Acharya, "The Tarkapada", JUG 4, 1953, 319-344

22.1.67 G.V.Devasthali, "Jaimini and Sabara on the interpretation of linga, vacana, bhakti, etc.", OT 1, 1955, 1-40

22.1.67.1 Books 3-4 translated by Susil Kumar Kar. Bangalore 1955

22.1.68 G.V.Devasthali, Mimamsa: The Vakya-Sastra of Ancient India. Bombay 1959

22.1.69 P.V.Kane, "Purvamimamsasutra, Brahmasutra, Jaimini, Vyasa and Badarayana", BDCRI 20, 1950, 119-130

22.1.69.8 P.V.Kane, "Purvamimamsasutra, Brahmasutra, Jainism, Vyasa, and Badaraayana", DCRIB 20, 1960, 119-139

22.1.70 Erich Frauwallner, "Mimamsasutram I.1.6-25", WZKSOA 5, 1961, 113-124

22.1.71 Samkarsakanda edited by K.V.Sarma. VIJ 1, 1963, i-xxiii, 1-25

22.1.72 Samkarsakanda edited, with Devasvamin's Bhasya, by S.Subrahmanya Sastri. AOR 19.1, 1964, 1-80; 19.2, 1964, 81-160; 20.1, 1965, 161-260

22.1.72.2 Edited by Devadatta Sarmopadhyaya Bareli 1969

22.1.72.1 Edited by Srirama Sarma. 1964, 1969

22.1.73 Chapter 4-10 edited, with Vasudeva Diksita's Kutuhalavrtti, by Pattabhirama Sastri. Two volumes. Delhi 1968, 1970, 1972

22.1.74 Edited with Sabara's Bhasya, Kumarila's Tantravarttika and Tuptika, by Kashinath Vasudeva Abhyankar and Gangesa Sastri Joshi. Four volumes. Second edition, Poona 1970-74

22.1.75 Krishan Gopal Goswami, "Incarnation of law from Mimamsa standpoint", CSFV 359-364

22.1.76 G.V.Devasthali, "Jaimini", VRFP 55-66

22.1.77 Edited with Sabara's Bhasya by Yudhisthira Mimamsaka. Bahalguda (Sonipat) 1977

22.1.78 Edited, with Bhavanatha Misra's Mimamsanayaviveka, Ravideva's Vivekatattva, and Varadaraja's Dipika, by Srinivasa Sastri Subrahmanyasastri. Vol. 1. New Delhi 1977

22.1.79 Edited by Aryamuni. Two volumes. Rohtak 1977

22.1.80 Edited with Sabara's Bhasya by Yudhisthira Mimamsaka. Five volumes. Bahalagada 1977

22.1.81 Edited with editor's Phalavati by Navalpakam Devanathacarya. Tanjore 1978

22.1.81.1 Edited with Sabara's Bhasya and Kumarila's Slokavartika. Ramesacandra Jaina Granthamala 1, Varanasi 1979

22.1.82 Asko Parpola, "On the formation of the Mimamsa and the problems concerning Jaimini", I: PJ 25, 1981, 145-178. II: WZKSOA 38, 1994, 294-308

22.1.83 Richard W. Lariviere, "Madhyamimamsa--the Sankarsakanda", PJ 25, 1981, 179-194.

22.1.84 N.S.Junankar, "The Mimamsa concept of dharma", JIP 10, 1982, 51-60

22.1.85 Translated by K.P.Bahadur as The Wisdom of Meemaansaa. Two volumes. New Delhi 1983

22.1.86 Francis Xavier Clooney, Retrieving the Purva Mimamsa of Jaimini. Ph.D.Thesis, University of Chicago 1984

22.1.87 Edited with Sabara's Bhasya, Somesvara Bhatta's Nyayasudha, Kumarila Bhatta's Tantravarttika, Govindamuni's Bhasya and Mahaprabhulal Gosvamin's Bhasya, by Pattabhirama Sastri and Mahaprabhulal Gosvamin. Three volumes. Varanasi 1984-

22.1.88 Francis X. Clooney, "Jaimini's contribution to the theory of sacrifice as the experience of transcendence", HistR 25, 1985, 57-75

22.1.88.1 Jean-Marie Verpoorten, "Le premier sutra de la Mimamsa et ses commentaires", Bulletin d'Etudes Indiennes 4, 1986, 353-366

22.1.88.2 Francis X. Clooney, "Dharmamatra karma (a re-evaluation of the Purva Mimamsa sutras II.1.9-12 with Sabarabhasya)", JOR 47-55, 1977-86, 157-168

22.1.89 Edited with Sabara's Bhasya by Brahmadatta Dwivedi. Varanasi 1987.

22.1.89.1 Edited, with Kumarila's Tantravarttika and Paritosa Misra's Ajita, by Kisor Natha (Sarma) Jha. Two volumes. Allahabad 1988, 1990

22.1.90 Atsusho Kanazawa, "Notes on the Sankarsa-kanda: under stimulus from the article by Lariviere", Acta Asiatica 57, 1989, 31-44

22.1.91.1 Edited by E.R.Sreekrishna Sarma. Madras 1989

22.1.92 Francis X. Clooney, Thinking Ritually: Rediscovering the Purva Mimamsa of Jaimini. Vienna 1990

22.1.92.1 Kunio Harikai, "Ajita and vijaya on the Apurva and two other adhikaranas (Mimamsasutra 2.1.5-12)", Acta Eurditiorum (Annual Report of the General Education, Saga Medical School)10, 1991, 1-24

22.1.93 Richard de Smet, S.J., "The presuppositions of Jaimini and the Vedantins", JICPR 11.2, 1994, 77-88

22.1.94.J.C.Heesterman, "Purusartha. Ein religions-hermeneutischer Versuch", HermE 137-152

22.1.95 S. L. Pandey and N.S.Dravid, "Comments on Richard de Smet's article 'The presuppositions of Jaimini and the Vedantins'", JICPR 13.1, 1995, 157-161

22.1.96 Edited and translated by Bangalore Suryanarain Rao. Delhi 1996

22.1.97 Edited Fairfield Iowa 1998

22.1.100 Translated by Madan Mohan Agrawala. 6SystIP 257-652

22.1.105 Edited by Kamalakanta Sukla. Varanasi 2005


23.Badarayana (50 A.D.)

See a22.1.35, 69; a235.1.15 1844.2.2. i29.1.38

     1.Brahmasutras or Vedantasutras

23.1.1 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and Samkara's Bhasyas on Katha, Kena and Mundaka Upanishads, by L. Poley. Paris 1837

23.1.2 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Anandagiri's Nyayanirnaya, by Anandacandra Vedantavagisa. Calcutta 1862

23.1.3 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Govindananda's Prabha and Vidyaranya's Vaiyasikanyayamala, by Rama Narayana Vidyaratna. BI 22, 1863

23.1.4 Edited, with Nilakantha's Bharatabhavadipika or Nilakanthi. Bombay 1863

23.1.5 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Govindananda's Ratnaprabha, and editor's Tippani, by K.A.Govindavishnu. Bombay 1867

23.1.6 Edited in Telugu characters, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya and Sudarsana's Srutaprakasika, by Srinivasacarya. Madras 1868

23.1.7 Translated, wiith Samkara's Bhasya, by K.M.Banerjee. BI 68, 1870; Osnabruck 1985

23.1.8 Edited, with Srikantha's Bhasya, by V.S.Tripathi. Pan 6, 1871-72 - 7, 1872-73. Incomplete

23.1.9 Edited in Telugu characters, with Samkara's Bhasya and Govindananda's Ratnaprabha, by Subrahmanya Suri. Madras 1872

23.1.10 Edited, with Madhva's Bhasya, by S. Samasramin. THC 5, 1872, 1-6, 8-12. Incomplete

23.1.11 Edited, with Madhva's Bhasya, by Jivananda Vidyasagara. Calcutta 1873, 1883, 1886

23.1.12 Translated into Dutch, with Samkara's Bhasya, by A. Bruining. Bijdragen to de taal, land- en volkenkunde van Nederlandsch-India 8, 1873 - 4.2, 1878

23.1.13 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Govindananda's Ratnaprabha and Vidyaranya's Vaiyasikanyayamala, by Jivananda Vidyasagara. Calcutta 1875

23.1.14 Edited with Prakasatman's Sarirakamimamsanyayasamgraha, by V. Sarma. Pan n.s. 3, 1878-79: 275, 348, 410. Incomplete

23.1.15 Edited in Telugu characters, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya and Sudarsana's Srutaprakasika. Vizagapatam 1879

23.1.16 Edited, with Bhairava Tilaka's Tatparyavivarana, by B. R. Tripathi. Pan n.s. 3, 1878-79 - 4, 1882. Revised by Kasinath Sarma, Banaras 1917

23.1.17 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati, by Bala Sastri. BI 83, 1880

23.1.18 Edited, with Madhva's Bhasya and Jayatirtha's Tattvaprakasika, by B. Ainapure and A. Astaputra. Bombay 1883

23.1.19 Edited, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, Sudarsana's Srutaprakasika, and editor's Tippani, by Rama Misra. Pan n.s. 7, 1885-19, 1897

23.1.20 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati, by Durgacaran Samkhyavedantatirtha. Four volumes. Calcutta 1886, 1932-33

23.1.21 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and Govindananda's Ratnaprabha. Banaras 1886

23.1.22 Edited, with Madhva's Bhasya and Jayatirtha's Tattvaprakasika, by Mahesacandra Pala. Calcutta 1886

23.1.23 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Govindananda's Ratnaprabha, Kesavananda Svamin's Ratnaprabhatippani and Vidyaranya's Vaiyasikanyayamala, by U. Ainapure. Bombay 1887

23.1.24 Translated into German according to Samkara's commentary by Paul Deussen in Die Sutras des Vedanta. Leipzig 1887, 1920

23.1.25 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Mahesacandra Pala. Calcutta 1887, 1910

23.1.26 Edited, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, by Ramanatha Tarkaratna. BI 117, 1888-1891

23.1.27 Edited in grantha characters, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya and Sudarsana's Srutaprakasika. Conjeeveram 1888

23.1.28 Edited with Samkarananda's Dipika. Banaras 1888

23.1.29 Edited, with Vallabha's Anubhasya, by Hemacandra Vidyabhusana. BI 116, 1888-1897

23.1.30 Edited, with Madhva's Bhasya and Jayatirtha's Tattvaprakasika. Bangalore 1889

23.1.31 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and Anandagiri's Nyayanirnaya, by N.S. Ekasambehare. Two volumes. ASS 21, 1890-91, 1900, 1903

23.1.32 Edited, with Nilakantha's Nilakanthi. Bombay 1890

23.1.33 Translated, with Samkara's Bhasya, by George Thibaut. SBE 34, 1890; 38, 1896. Two volumes. Reprinted New York 1962

23.1.34 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati, by Jivananda Vidyasagara. Calcutta 1891

23.1.35 Edited, with Madhva's Bhasya and Raghavendra's Tattvamanjari, by T.R.Krishnacarya. Bombay 1891

23.1.36 Partly edited, with Krsnananda Sarasvati's Kutuhala, by Narayana Shastri Patwardhan. Banaras 1895, 1952

23.1.37 Edited, with Madhva's Bhasya and Jayatirtha's Tattvaprakasika, by R.B.Reddy. Dharwar 1896; Poona 1927

23.1.38 Translated, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, by M. Rangacarya and M.B.Varadaraja Aiyangar. Three volumes. Madras 1899; 1961-65

23.1.38.1 Edited, with Rangaramanuja's Dipika, by Laksmanacarya. Bombay 1898, 1899

23.1.39 Edited, with Nilakantha's Nilakanthi. Calcutta 1899, 1904

23.1.40 Partially translated, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya and Vatsya Varada's Prapannaparijata. BV 5, 1900: 3, 17, 65, 90, 165, 293, 317, 379

23.1.41 Edited, with Madhva's Bhasya and Jagannatha's Dipika on it, by Gopalakrsnacarya. Madras 1900

23.1.42 Edited in Telugu characters, with Ramananda Sarasvati's Brahmamrtavarsini, by Annavaram Venkataraghava Sarma. Nellore 1900

23.1.43 Edited, with Vijnanabhiksu's Vijnanamrta, by M.S. Adkar. ChSS 8, 1901

23.1.44 Edited, with Srikantha's Bhasya, by L. Srinivasacarya. MOLP 30, 1903

23.1.44.1 Edited by Vindhyesvari Prasada Dvivedin. ChSS 20, 1903

23.1.45 Edited, with Ramananda Sarasvati's Brahmamrtavarsini, by S. Venkataramana Aiyer. Pan n.ss. 25 (1903) - 38 (1916). Reprinted 1916

23.1.46 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Anandagiri's Nyayanirnaya, Govindananda's Ratnaprabha and Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati, by M.S.Bakre and R.S.Dhupakar. Bombay 1904, 1934

23.1.47 Edited in Tamil characters, with Samkara's Bhasya and extracts from Anandagiri's Nyayanirnaya, Amrtananda's Brahmavidyabharana and Ramananda Sarasvati's Brahmamrtavarsini, by Siva Row. Madras 1904

23.1.48 Edited, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, by J.J.Johnson. Pan n.s. 26 (1904) - 36 (1914). Reprinted Banaras 1915

23.1.49 Book I.1.1-4 edited, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya and editor's gloss, by V.S.Abhyankar. Poona 1904, 1965

23.1.50 Translated, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, by George Thibaut. SBE 48, 1904. Reprinted New York. Portions reprinted in Source Book, 543-555

23.1.51 Edited in Telugu characters, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya and Vedanta Desika's Tattvatika, by Perangattur Ghantavataracarya. Conjeeveram 1904, 1906

23.1.52 Edited, with Nimbarka's Vedantaparijatasaurabha, Srinivasa's Vedantakaustubha and Kesava Kasmiri's Vedantakaustubhaprabha, by Nityasvarupa Brahmacarin. Vrndavana 1904

23.1.53 Translated, with Madhva's Bhasya, by S. Subba Rau. Madras 1904; Tirupati 1936. Portions reprinted in Source Book, 555-572.

23.1.54 Edited, with Samkarananda's Dipika and Mahadeva Sarasvati's Tattvanusamdhana, by Rama Sastri Tailanga. BenSS 24, 1904-06

23.1.55 Edited with Samkara's Bhasya by M. Ramanujacharyar. Madras 1905

23.1.56 Edited with Samkara's Bhasya by Sarvananda. Lahore 1905

23.1.57 Edited with Madhva's Bhasya by Krishnacarya Puranika. Dharwar 1905

23.1.58 Edited, with Vrajanatha's Maricika, by Ratna Gopala Bhatta. ChSS 4, 1905

23.1.59 Edited in grantha characters, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, Sudarsana's Srutaprakasika and Rangaramanuja's Bhavaprakasika, by V.N.Krishnamacharya. Kumbakonam 1906-08

23.1.60 Edited, with editor's Vedantanavamalika, by T.Nilamegha Sastrin. Madras 1906

23.1.60.1 Edited with Nimbarka's Dasasloki, Devacarya's Siddhantajahnavi, Sundara Bhatta's Dvaitadvaitasiddhantasataka and Giridhara Prapanna's Laghumanjusa, by P. Dundhiraja Sastri. ChSS 26, 1906, 1927

23.1.61 Edited, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, Srinivasa's Yatindramatadipika and an anonymous Varttika, by Ratna Gopal Bhatta. BenSS 28, 1907

23.1.62 Edited, with Madhva's Bhasya and Subbarayacarya's Sutrarthamanimanjari, by Setumadhvacarya. Madras 1907

23.1.63 Edited in grantha and Tamil characters, with Srikantha's Bhasya, by Kasivasi Sendinath Aiyar. Tirumangalam 1907

23.1.64 Edited, with Vallabha's Anubhasya and Purusottama's Prakasa, by Ratna Gopal Bhatta. BenSS 26, 1907

23.1.65 Edited by Lakharaja Agarwala. Bombay 1908

23.1.66 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, by K.V. Lele. Three volumes. Poona 1908: Wai 1909-1911

23.1.67 Edited in Telugu characters, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, Sudarsana's Srutaprakasika and Ramanuja's Vedantasara and Vedantadipa, by Gargya Paravastu Ramanuja. Madras 1908

23.1.68 Edited, with Srikantha's Bhasya, Appayya Diksita's Sivakarmanidipika, and editor's Sutrarthacandrika, by R. Halasyanatha Sastri. Bombay, Kumbakonam 1908-1919

23.1.69 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Govindananda's Ratnaprabha, Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati, Anandagiri's Nyayanirnaya, and editor's Tippani on Bhamati, by Mahadeva Sarma Bakre. 1909

23.1.70 Edited, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, Vedantasara and Vedantadipa and Vedanta Desika's Adhikaranasaravali, by A.V.Narasimhacarya and T.C.V.Narasimhacarya. Two volumes. Madras 1909-1910

23.1.71 Edited in Telugu characters, with Madhva's Bhasya, by Vaiyyu Srinivasacarya. Madras 1909

23.1.72 Edited, with Sadasiva's Tattvaprakasika, by T. Ganapati Sastri. TSS 7, 1909

23.1.73 Edited, with Sadasiva's Tattvaprakasika, by T.K. Balasubrahmanyam. SVVSS 6, 1909

23.1.74 Books I and II edited, with Bodhananda Bharati's Nrsimhasarirakabhasya. Vizianagaram 1909-1912

23.1.75 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, in WSS

23.1.76 Edited, with Nimbarka's Vedantaparijatasaurabha, by V.P. Dvivedin. ChSS 34, 1910

23.1.77 Edited, with Raghavendra Tirtha's Tantradipika, by T.R. Krishnacarya. Belgaum 1910

23.1.78 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, by V.S.Abhyankar. Poona 1911

23.1.79 Edited, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, by Durgacarana Samkhyavedantatirtha. Calcutta 1911-1916

23.1.80 Edited, with Ramananda Sarasvati's Brahmamrtavarsini, by Prajnananda Saraswati Swami. ChSS 36, 1911

23.1.81 Edited up to I.1.39, with Madhva's Bhasya, Jayatirtha's Tattvaprakasika, Vyasatirtha's Tatparyacandrika and Raghavendra's Prakasa, by R. Raghavendracarya. Four volumes. MOLP 39, 1911; 47, 1915; 53, 1920; 59, 1922. Reprinted 1984

23.1.82 Edited, with Samkarananda's Dipika and Ramananda Sarasvati's Brahmamrtavarsini, by Anandasrama pandits. ASS 67, 1911

23.1.83 Edited, with Nimbarka's Vedantaparijatasaurabha, by Tarakisora Sarma Chaudhuri. Calcutta 1912

23.1.84 Book One edited, with Mahacarya's Parasaryavijaya, by P.B. Ananthachariar. SMS 43, 1912

23.1.85 Edited in Telugu characters, with Srinivasacarya's Tattvaratnavali and Manimanjusika, by Sadanantapurusa Simha. Conjeeveram 1912

23.1.86 Translated, with Baladeva Vidyabhusana's Govindabhasya and Prameyaratnavali, by S.C.Vasu. SBH 5, 1910, 1912, 1934, 1974; New Delhi 1979

23.1.87 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati and Anandagiri's Nyayanirnaya, by Venkatacalasastri and Chotupati Sastri. Bombay 1913

23.1.88 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati, Amalananda's Kalpataru, Appayya Diksita's Parimala and Laksminrsimha's Abhoga, by a committee of scholars. SVVSS 2, 1914-1915

23.1.89 Edited, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, by V.S.Abhyankar. Two volumes. BSPS 68, 1914; 72, 1916

23.1.90 Published with Vaidikavrtti by Hariprasada Svamin. Hardwar, Bombay 1914; Varanasi 1982

23.1.91 Edited, with Samkarabhagavatpada's Vrtti, by Harihara Sastri. AManjS 4, 1914

23.1.92 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and P.Subrahmanya Sastri's Artharatnamala, by Y.G.Gokhale. ASS 75, 1915

23.1.93 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Vasudeva Laksmana Sastri Pansikar. Bombay 1915, 1927

23.1.94 Partially edited, with Bhaskara's Bhasya, by V.P.Dvivedin. ChSS 20, 1951 ff.

23.1.95 Edited, with Rangaramanuja's Arthadipika, by K.N. Krishnamacharya. Kumbakonam 1915-1919

23.1.96 Edited, with Gauda Brahmananda Sarasvati's Muktavali, by V.S.R.Gokhale. ASS 77, 1915

23.1.97 Book I.1.1-4 edited, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya and Sudarsana's Srutaprakasika, by T. Srinivasa Sarma. Bombay 1916

23.1.98 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati, Amalananda's Kalpataru and Appayya Diksita's Parimala, by N.S.Anantakrishna Sastri and V.L.S.Pansikar. Bombay 1915, 1917, 1938, 1948, 2000

23.1.99 Book One translated into German, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, by Rudolf Otto as Siddhanta des Ramanuja. Jena 1917; Tubingen 1923

23.1.100 Edited, with Samkarananda's Dipika, by Nagendra Natha Sastri. Calcutta 1917

23.1.101 Edited, with Haridiksita's Vrtti, by Vaidya Ranjanatha Sastri. ASS 82, 1917

23.1.102 S.K.Belvalkar, "The multiple authorship of the Vedanta-Sutras", IPR 2, 1918-19, 141-154

23.1.103 V.S.Ghate, Le Vedanta: études sur les Brahmasutra et leurs cinq commentaires. Paris 1918. English version: The Vedanta: A Study of the Brahma-sutras with the Bhasyas of Samkara, Ramanuja, Nimbarka, Madhva and Vallabha. Poona 1926

23.1.104 M.T.Telivala, Discuss How Far Sankaracharya Truly Represents the View of the Author of the Brahmasutras. Bombay 1918. Reprinted Teliwala 48-128

23.1.105 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati, Vidyaranya's Vaiyasikanyayamala, Govindananda's Ratnaprabha, Amalananda's Sastradarpana, by Pramathanatha Tarkabhusana. Three volumes. Calcutta 1918-1921

23.1.106 R.D.Karmarkar, "Comparison of the bhasyas of Samkara, Ramanuja, Kesavakasmiraka and Vallabha on some crucial sutras", ABORI 2, 1920-21, 105-127; 3, 1921-22, 23-61

23.1.107 Edited in grantha and Tamil characters, with Van Sathakopa's Bhasyarthamanipravaladipika, by Gopala Tillaiyampur Cakravarti and T.H.Venkatacarya. Kumbakonam 1920

23.1.108 Edited in Tamil characters, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, by Kunnapakam Srinivasacarya. Conjeeveram 1921

23.1.109 Book I.1.1-3 edited, with Vallabha's Anubhasya, Muralidhara's Vyakhya, Giridhara's Vedantacandrika, Lalubhatta's Gudharthadipika and Iccharama's Pradipa, by Rama Natha Sastri. Bombay 1921

23.1.110 Abhaya Kumar Guha, Jivatman in the Brahmasutras. Calcutta 1921

23.1.111 Edited, with Vallabha's Anubhasya and editor's Balabodhini, by Sridhara (Tryambaka) Sastri Pathaka. BSPS 77, 1921; 91, 1926. Two volumes

23.1.112 R.D.Karmarkar, "The relation of the Bhagavadgita and the Badarayana Sutras", ABORI 3, 1921-22, 73-79

23.1.113 Published with Girindranatha Vedantaratna's Tattvaprabodhini. Mymensingh 1922

23.1.114 Book I.1 edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, by S.K.Belvalkar. Poona 1923

23.1.115 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and Vidyaranya's Vaiyasikanyayamala, by V.V.Bapat. Poona 1923

23.1.116 Edited in Telugu characters, with Madhva's Bhasya, in Ahnikapaddhati (Tirupati, 1923-24)

23.1.117 V.V.Mirashi, "The traditional author of the Vedanta-Sutras--Badarayana or Krsna Dvaipayana", PAIOC 2, 1923, 463-470

23.1.118 Barend Faddegon, "The chapter III.3, the method of exegesis in the Vedantasutra", ActOD 1, 1923, 105-113

23.1.119 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati, by Abhayakumara Sarma. Calcutta 1924

23.1.120 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and notes from various commentaries, by V.V.Bapat. Five volumes. Poona 1924-25

23.1.121 Edited, with Sadasiva's Tattvaprakasika, by N.S. Aiyar. Triplicane 1925

23.1.122 Y. Kanakura, "Über die interpolation des Sankarabhasya zum Brahmasutra", BZLGI 381-385

23.1.123 Book I.1.1-13 translated, with Madhva's Bhasya and Jayatirtha's Tattvaprakasika, in The Ekantin, Dharwar 1926 ff.

23.1.124 Edited, with Krsna Sastri Karunga's Brahmasutranugunyasiddhi, by Harihara Sastri. Kumbakonam 1926

23.1.125 Edited in Telugu characters, with Madhva's Bhasya, by Humdi Ramara Pantulu. Vizianagaram 1927-28

23.1.126 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, in WS

23.1.127.1 G.S.Sarma, "The authorship of the Vedanta Sutras", Jignyasa 1.3, 1927, 1-2

23.1.128 Pratap M. Modi, "Badarayana and Gaudapada", PAIOC 5, Summaries 1928, 120-121

23.1.129 Edited, with Vallabha's Anubhasya, Purusottama's Prakasa and Gopesvara's Rasmi, by M.T.Telivala. Four volumes. Bombay 1925-1942. Introductory material reprinted in Telivala 155-174, 207-212

23.1.130 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Govindananda's Prabha, and Purnananda's Purnanandi, by Dundhiraja Sastri. Two volumes. KSS 71, 1929-31

23.1.131 Edited, with Ramananda Sarasvati's Brahmamrtavarsini, Ramananda's Anandabhasya and editor's commentary, by Raghuvaradasa Vedantin. Ahmedabad 1929

23.1.131.5 Edited, with Purusottama Prasada's Vedantakarikamala, the Bhavaprakasika (A.U.) on that, and Chapter Four of Gopesvara's (Caturartha)Adhikaranavali. Kishangarh 1922-1925, 1929, 1981

23.1.132 Edited, with Nilakantha's Nilakanthi. Citrasala, Poona 1929-36

23.1.133 Published, with Kalikesa Vandhyopadhyaya's Vyakhya. Calcutta 192

23.1.134 Translated, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, by V.K.Ramanujachari. Three volumes. Kumbakonam 1930. Part of this reprinted as The Three Tattvas (Kumbakonam 1932)

23.1.135 Edited, with Nimbarka's Vedantaparijatasaurabha and editor's Vedantasubodhini, by Santadasa Vayavidehi. Allahabad, Daulatpur 1930, 1932

23.1.136 Umesha Chandra Bhattacharya, "Progress of Brahma Vidya from the Upanishads to the Sutras", PAIOC 5, 1930, 809-841

23.1.137 Book I.1.1-4 edited, with Madhva's Bhasya and Padmanabhatirtha's Sannyayaratnavali. Dharwar 1930

23.1.138 Book II.1-2 edited and translated, with Samkara's Bhasya and extensive notes, by S.K.Belvalkar. Second edition. Poona 1931

23.1.139 Book III.3.1-9 translated into German, with Samkara's Bhasya and Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati, by Otto Strauss in Udgithavidya (1931)

23.1.140 Sutras of the various versions collated by Kapilesvara Misra and edited by Nityanandavinoda Gosvamin as Brahmasutras (Santiniketan 1931)

23.1.141 Book I.1.1-4 edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and editor's commentary, by R.S.Sarma.  Moradabad 1931

23.1.142 Edited, with Nimbarka's Vedantaparijatasaurabha and Srinivasa's Vedantakaustubha, by Dundhiraja Sastri. KSS 99. 1932

23.1.142.1 Kapilesvara Misra and Nityananda Vinoda Gosvami, Brahmasutras of Badarayana as Read by Different Comentators. Calcutta 1932

23.1.143 Book I.1.1-4 edited and translated, with Samkara's Bhasya and Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati, by S.Suryanarayana Sastri and C. Kunhan Raja. Adyar 1933; Madras 1992

23.1.144 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Padmapada's Pancapadika, Prakasatman's Vivarana, Visnubhatta's Rjuvivarana, Akhandananda's Tattvadipana, Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati, Citsukha's Bhavaprakasika, Narayana Sarasvati's Varttika, Akhandananda Sarasvati's Rjuprakasika and editor's Pradipa, by N.S.Anantakrishna Sastri. CalSS 1, 1933

23.1.145 Aksaya Kumar Banerjea, "Brahmasutra and adhyasa-vada", PQ 9, 1933-34, 222-234

23.1.146 P.M.Modi, "Pre-Samkara mutilation of the text of the Brahmasutras: some suggestions for corrections", PAIOC 7, 1933, 433-437

23.1.147 S.C.Vasu, Studies in the Vedanta Sutras. Second edition. SBH 3, 1933

23.1.148 Book I.1.1-5 edited, with Madhva's Bhasya, Jayatirtha's Tattvaprakasika, Padmanabhatirtha's Sattarkadipavali on I.1.1-4, and Trivikrama's Tattvapradipa, by B.N.Krishnamurti Sharma. Madras 1934

23.1.149 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, by D.S.Nyayopadhyaya. KSS 116, 1935

23.1.150 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and Anubhuti Svarupacarya's Prakatarthavivarana, by T.R.Chintamani. 56 pp. English summary in Volume Two. Two volumes. MUSS 9, 1935-39

23.1.151 Edited, with Nilakantha's Nilakanthi, by S.G.S.Sahale. 1935-38

23.1.152 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and Govindananda's Ratnaprabha, by Bhole Baba. Banaras 1935

23.1.152.1 Edited with Samkara's Bhasya by K.S.Ramaswami Sastri. 1935

23.1.153 P.M.Modi, "Problem of the tad uktam sutras in the Brahmasutras: sutra III.4.42", ABORI 18, 1936, 351-356

23.1.154 Vireswarananda, "Samkara's interpretation of the Vedanta Sutras", PB 41, 1936, 765-772

23.1.155 Edited, with Prakasatman's Sarirakamimamsanyayasamgraha, by T.R.Chintamani. AOR 1, 1936-37 - 4, 1939-40. Reprinted Madras 1939

23.1.156 Edited, with Sripati's Srikarabhasya, by C. Hayavadana Rao. Two volumes. Bangalore 1936

23.1.157 P.M.Modi, "The meaning of smrti in the Brahmasutras", IHQ 2, 1936, 714-718

23.1.158 P.M.Modi, "Destiny of the brahmajnanin in the light of the Brahmasutras", PAIOC 9, 1937, 539-547

23.1.159 I.1.1 with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, translated into French by Olivier Lacombe as Les Grands Theses de Ramanuja (Paris 1938) and as La Doctrine Morale et Metaphysique de Ramanuja (Paris 1938)

23.1.160 Translated, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, by Vireswarananda. PB 43, 1938 - 45, 1960

23.1.161 Book I.1.1-4 edited and translated, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Har Dutt Sharma. POS 70, 1940, 1967

23.1.162 Translated, with Nimbarka's Vedantaparijatasaurabha and Srinivasa's Vedantakaustubha, by Roma Chaudhuri Bose. BI 259, 1940-43

23.1.163 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Prakasatman's Sarirakanyayasamgraha, Narayana Sarasvati's Varttika, Citsukha's Bhavaprakasika, Adhikaranamanjari and Adhikaranasamgati, Krsnananda's Adhikarananukramanika and editor's Sarirakanyayasamgrahadipika and Pradipa, by N.S.Anantakrishna Sastri. CalSS 1, 1941

23.1.164 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and Govindananda's Ratnaprabha, by Krishna Pant. Three volumes. AG 5, 1942

23.1.165 Book One edited, with Vallabha's Anubhasya and Giridhara's Vivarana, by Harishankar Omkaraji Shastri. Bombay 1942

23.1.166 Edited, with Vanamali Misra's Siddhantamuktavali, by Balacarya Madhavacarya Khuparkar. ASS 117, 1942

23.1.167 B.N.Krishnamurti Sarma, "The sutras of Badarayana", ABORI 23, 1942, 398-404

23.1.168 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Bhaskara's Bhasya, Ramanuja's Sribhasya, Nimbarka's Vedantaparijatasaurabha, Madhva's Bhasya, Srikantha's Bhasya, Vallabha's Anubhasya and Vijnanabhiksu's Bhasya, in Brahmasutrabhasyanirnaya (Banaras 1943)

23.1.169 P.M.Modi, "Defects of the traditional method of interpreting the Brahmasutras", PAIOC 12, 1943, 361-369

23.1.170 P.V.Subrahmanya Sastri, "Is Vyasa the same as Badarayana?", JSVRI 7.2, 1946, 176-179

23.1.171 Translated, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Vireswarananda. Second edition.  Almore 1948

23.1.172 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya by N.R.Acarya. Third edition. Bombay 1948

23.1.173 Edited and translated by Sivananda. Rishikesh 1949; Delhi 1977

23.1.174 Book II edited, with Vallabha's Anubhasya and Giridhara's Vivarana, by G.H.Bhatt. Bombay 1950

23.1.175 Edited, with Annambhatta's Vrttimitaksara, by P.B.Rama Sastri. MGOS 18, 1950

23.1.176 Part One edited and translated into French, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Louis Renou in Prolegomènes au Vedanta (Paris 1951)

23.1.177 Vireswarananda, "A comparative study of the commentaries on the Brahmasutras", PB 58, 1953: 50, 97, 140, 181, 220, 260, 300

23.1.178 P.M.Modi, "Badarayana's conception of Brahman", JASBo 29, 1954, 44-54

23.1.179 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, in SSG 1-2

23.1.180 Edited and translated in Vinayak Hari Date, Vedanta Explained: Samkara's Commentary on the Brahmasutras. Two volumes. Bombay 1954-1959; 1973

23.1.181 P.M.Modi, "Departure of the seeker from the body (a fresh study of Brahmasutra IV.2)", ABORI 36, 1955, 54-61

23.1.182 P.M.Modi, "Badarayana and Samkara: a fresh study", JGJRI 14, 1956-57, 23-37

23.1.183 Translated, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Vasudeva Sastri Abhyankar and Dinkar Tryambak Chandrokar. Second edition. Poona 1957

23.1.184 P.M.Modi, "Relation between the Bhagavadgita and the Brahmasutra", PAIOC 19, part II, 1957, 136-139

23.1.185 Edited, with Madhva's Bhasya and Trivikrama's Tattvapradipa, by the Akhila Bharata Madhva Maha Mandal. Udipi 1958

23.1.186 P.D.Candatre, Methodology of the Major Bhasyas on the Brahma Sutra. Navsari 1958

23.1.187 Edited and translated, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, by R.D. Karmarkar. Three volumes. Poona 1959-1964

23.1.188 Translated, with Srikantha's Bhasya, by Roma Chaudhuri. Calcutta 1959

23.1.189 Hajime Nakamura, "The concept of Brahman in the Brahma-Sutras", IAC 9, 1959-60, 176-186

23.1.190 Translated, with Samkara's Bhasya, by V.H.Date. Two volumes. Bombay 1960

23.1.191 Translated, with Samkara's Bhasya, by V.M.Apte. Bombay 1960

23.1.192 P.M.Modi, "Refutation of the Samkhya theory of creation in Brahmasutra II.2.1-10, with special reference to Samkara Bhasya on the same", GRSJ 22, 1960, 336-342

23.1.193 Translated by Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan, with summaries of the major commentaries on each sutra, in The Brahma Sutra (London 1960)

23.1.194 Paul Hacker, "Ein prasthana-traya-kommentar des Neue-hinduismus", OL 1961, 565-576. Translated into Englilsh by Wilhelm Halbfass, PhilCon 337-350

23.1.195 Venkata Subrahmanya Sastri, "Is Vyasa the same as Badarayana?", JGJRI 18, 1961-62, 83-88

23.1.196 Louis Renou, "Sur la forme de quelques textes sanscrits: 4. Les Brahmasutra", JA 249, 1961, 197-211

23.1.197 Books III-IV edited, with Vallabha's Anubhasya and Giridhara's Vivarana, by G.H.Bhatt. Nathadwar, Rajasthan 1962

23.1.198 Edited, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya and editor's Bhasyarthadarpana on it, by U.T.Viraraghavacarya. Madras 1963-64.

23.1.199 Edited, with Ramananda Sarasvati's Brahmamrtavarsini and editor's Vrtti, by Bhagavadacarya. Varanasi 1963

23.1.201 T.N.Dave, "The text of the Vedantasutra", SPP 3.1, 1963, 26-29

23.1.201.1 Edited by Harikrishnadas Goenka. Gorakhpur 1963

23.1.202 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Hanumanadasa Sastri. Varanasi 1964

23.1.203 Edited, with Raghavendra Tirtha's Tantradipika, by R.S.Panchamukhi. Dharwar 1964

23.1.204 P.M.Modi, "Brahmasutra II.2.37-45--a fresh interpretation", JOI 14, 1964, 52-54

23.1.205 Edited with editor's commentary by Raghavendra Svamirayacarya Pancamukhi. Dharwar 1964

23.1.206 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Satcidanandendra Sarasvati. Three volumes.  Holenarsipur 1964-1970

23.1.207 Translated, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Gambhirananda. Calcutta 1965

23.1.208 S.R.Bhatt, "Does Badarayana favour Pancaratra?", PQ 38, 1965, 47-54

23.1.209 T.N.Dave, "Role of udaharana (illustrations) in Vedanta-sutras", SPP 5.1, 1965, 1-5

23.1.210 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Satyananda Sarasvati. Varanasi 1965.

23.1.211 Book II.2 edited and translated, with Samkara's Bhasya, by S.N.Gajendragadkar. Bombay 1965

23.1.212 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Visvesvara Siddhanta Siromani. Varanasi 1966

23.1.213 Edited, with Ramanandacarya's Anandabhasya, by Vaisnavacarya. Ahmedabad 1966

23.1.214 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Visvesvaracarya. Vidyabhavana Sanskrit Granthamala 137, 1966

23.1.215 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Viramani Prasad Upadhyaya. Varanasi 1967

23.1.216 M.V.Joshi, "A fresh interpretation of the views of Asmarathya, Audulomi, and Kasakrtsna as given in Brahmasutra I.4.20-22", SPP 7, 1967, 14-21

23.1.217 Edited, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya and Sudarsana's Srutaprakasika, by U. Viraraghavacarya. Two volumes. Madras 1967

23.1.218 Edited, with Madhva's Bhasya, Jayatirtha's Tattvaprakasika and Raghunatha Tirtha's Sesatatparyacandrika, by the editors of the Poornaprajna Research Institute. Volume One. Bangalore 1967

23.1.219 P.M.Modi, "Brahmasutrakara as interpreter of Gita", JGJRI 24, 1968, 139-150

23.1.220 Ramjee Singh, "Examination of Brahma Sutra II.2.33", ProcIPC 1968, 136-141. Also Darshana 34, 1969, 33-39

23.1.221 Edited, with Baladeva Vidyabhusana's Govindabhasya, by Bhaktisvarupa Siddhantin. Four volumes. 1968-1970

23.1.222 T.K.Gopalaswamy Ayyangar, "Vamadeva's philosophy as enshrined in the Brahmasutras", PAIOC, Summaries 1969, 234-235

23.1.223 Published with Vidyananda Giri's Vidyanandavrtti. Varanasi 1969

23.1.224 III.1-2 edited with Samkara's Bhasya by A.G.Krishna Warrier. Trivandrum 1970-71

23.1.225 K.R.Potdar, "The purvapaksa in the samanvayadhikarana", BhV 30, 1970, 29-55

23.1.226 V.Venkatachalam, "Two untraced citations in Brahmasutrabhasya of Samkara", JOR 40-41, 1970-72, 101-104

23.1.227 B.N.Krishnamurti Sarma, The Brahmasutras and Their Principal Commentaries. Three volumes. Bombay 1971-1978

23.1.228 D.T.Tatacharya, "'Me' means Brahman", FRSD 197-199

23.1.229 Edited, with Sudarsanacarya's Srutapradipika, by A. Srinivasa Raghavan. 1972

23.1.229.1 Ram Sharan Tripathi, Brahmasutra-pramukhabhasya-pancaka-samiksamani: Being a Critical and Comparative Study of the Five Main Bhasyas, viz., by Samkara, Ramanuja, Madhva, Nimbarka and Vallabha on the Brahmasutras of Badarayana. Ph.D. Thesis, Agra University 1963; KSS 213, 1972

23.1.230 Edited, with Madhva's Bhasya. Poona 1973

23.1.231 Edited, with Baladeva Vidyabhusana's Govindabhasya, autocommentary thereon and Siddhantaratna, by Bhaktivedanta Baman. Nadia 1973

23.1.232 Edited, with Vidyaranya's Vaiyasikanyayamala, by Satyananda Sarasvati Svami.  Varanasi 1973

23.1.233 Translated, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Saccidananda Sarasvati. Bangalore 1974

23.1.234 Hajime Nakamura, "The historico-social attitude of the Brahma-Sutras", CDSFV 373-378

23.1.234.1 Shiv Kumar, "Criticism of the Samkhya-theory in the Brahma- Sutra 1.4.1-7". CASSt 2, 1974, 141-153

23.1.235 B.N.K.Sarma, "Importance and scope of the Brahmasutras", VRFV 361-367

23.1.236 Book II.2 edited in Telugu script, with Samkara's Bhasya, by Patibanda Suryanarayanamatyulu. Guntur 1975

23.1.237 D.N.Shanbhag, "The problem of the authorship of the Brahmasutras: Madhva's contribution toward its solution", KUJ 19, 1975, 23-30. Also DhP 7.10, 1978, 49-58

23.1.238 T.M.P.Mahadevan, "Badarayana", VRFP 67-84

23.1.239 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati and Govindananda Sarasvati's Ratnaprabha, by Mahaprabhu Lal Gosvami. Part One. Muzaffarpur 1976

23.1.240 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya and Advaitananda's Brahmavidyabharana, by S.R.Krishnamurti Sastri. Two volumes. Madras 1976-1979

23.1.240.1 Shiv Kumar, "Criticism of the Samkhya-theory in the Iksatyadhikarana of the Brahma-Sutra", CASSt 3, 1976, 81-90

23.1.241 T.G.Mainkar, "Some thoughts on the Brahmasutras and the Bhagavadgita", ABORI 58-59, 1977-78, 745-755

23.1.242 B.N.K.Sarma, "Have mukta-jivas any master or ruler over them in Badarayana's philosophy?", DhP 8.1, 1977, 21-26

23.1.243 Book I.1-4 edited and translated, with Ramanuja's Sribhasya, by Vireswarananda and Adidevananda. Calcutta 1977, 1978

23.1.244 Batuknath Bhattacharya, "Brahma Sutras--a conspectus", Dilip 5.2, 1978, 10-16

23.1.245 R. Balasubramanian, "On the nature of avidya", JMU 49.1.2, 1977, 80-85

23.1.246 R. Balasubramanian, "Neither the known nor the unknown", JMU 49.2.2, 1977, 74-82

23.1.246.1 Arvind Sharma, "Is Brahmasutra I.3.34-35 an independent sutra?", Studia Orentalia 48, 197, 6 pp.

23.1.248 Brahmachari Vinaya Chaitanya, "A brief introduction to the Brahmasutras", STM 85-87

23.1.249 Selected passages translated, with Madhva's Brahmasutrabhasya thereon, by V. Nagarajachar. DhP 8, 1979, 68-79

23.1.250 B.N.K.Sharma, Avirodha adhyaya, DhP 8.5, 1979, 12-19

23.1.251 Edited by Haridasa Sastrin. Vrndaban 1979

23.1.252 Tomasz Rucinski, "Some notes about the reading of Brahmasutras' teaching", LSFV 603-606

23.1.253 Edited, with Vidyaranya's Vaiyasikanyayamala, by Sivadatta. Poona 1980

23.1.254 Edited, with Rangaramanuja's Sariradhikaranasamgati and Simhadasa's Acaryapancasat and Aryamangalamalika, with editor's Divyacaritaratnavali, by Simhadasa. Bangalore 1980

23.1.255 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Govindananda's Ratnaprabha, Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati and Anandagiri's Nyayanirnaya, by J.L.Shastri. Delhi 1980, 1988

23.1.255.1 S.S.Raghavachar, "Anandamayadhikarana", SRV 3.4, 1980, 5-12 

23.1.256 Edited, with Madhva's Brahmasutrabhasya, Jayatirtha's Tattvaprakasika and Raghavendratirtha's Bhavadipa, by R.S.Panchamukhi. Four volumes. Dharwar 1980-81

23.1.257 N.M.Kansara, "The treatment of the pancagni-vidya on the Brahmasutras III.1", Sambodhi 10, 1981-82, 42-49

23.1.258 Partly edited with Madhva's Bhasya and Padmanabhatirtha's Sattarkadipavali, by Katti Kesavacarya. Bangalore 1981

23.1.259 Edited, with Jayatirtha's Tattvaprakasika and Vyasatirtha's Tatparyacandrika. Three volumes. Mysore 1981-

23.1.260 Edited, with Praudha Devaraya's Vrtti, by K.S.Varadacarya. Mysore 1982

23.1.261 S.M.Bhatkande, The Chandogya Upanisad and the Brahmasutras of Badarayana. A Comparative Study. Bombay 1982

23.1.262 Edited by Aryamuni. Rohtak 1982

23.1.262.1 Gregory Joseph Darling, An Evaluation of the Vedantic Critique of Buddhism in Three Commentaries to the Brahmasutras. Ph.D.Thesis, Columbia University 1982; Ann Arbor 1985

23.1.263 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Vacaspati Misra's Bhamati and editor's Vyakhya, by Yogindrananda. Two volumes. Varanasi 1982-84

23.1.264 Edited, with editor's Saktibhasya, by Pancanana Tarkaratna Bhattacharya in A Commentary on the Brahmasutras of Badarayana. Two volumes. Delhi 1984

23.1.265 Edited and translated by Vidyananda Sarasvati. Bombay 1985

23.1.266 Edited with Samkara's Bhasya. 1985

23.1.267 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Anandagiri's Vyakhya, Ramanuja's Sribhasya, Vedanta Desika's Tattvatika, Madhva's Bhasya and Jayatirtha's Prameyadipika on it, Hanuman's Paisacabhasya, Venkatanatha's Brahmanandagiri, Vallabha's Tattvadipika, Purusottama's Amrtatarangini, Nilakantha's Bhavadipa, Yamuna's Arthasamgraha and Vedanta Desika's Raksa, by Gajanana Sambhu Sadhale. Three volumes. Parimal Sanskrit Series 17, Delhi 1985

23.1.268 Jose Pereira, "Badarayana: creator of systematic theology", Religious Studies 22, 1986, 193-204

23.1.268.1 S. Ranganath, "Arrangement and contents of Brahmasutras", TL 9.1, 1986, 23-25

23.1.268.2 S. Ranganath, "Vedantasutras occupy a central position in Vedantic thought", TL 9.2, 1986, 23-24

23.1.268.3 S. Ranganath, "Grounds for different interpretations of Brahmasutras", TL 19.3 1986, 28-30

23.1.269 Catuhsutri edited, with Srikantha's Bhasya and Appayya Diksita's Sivarkamanidipika, by Vrajavallabha Dviveda. Varanasi 1986

23.1.269.1. S.S., "Brahma Sutra", TL 11.2, 1988, 33-40

23.1.269.2 George Clifton Adams, Jr., The Structure and Meaning of Badarayana's Brahmasutras. An Analysis and Translation of Adhyaya I. Ph.D.Thesis, Fordham University 1988

23.1.270 V.R.Panchamukham, Badarayana's Brahma Sutras. Essentials of Madhva Philosophy. Delhi 1989

23.1.271 Yashodhara Wadhwani (Shah), "Badarayana's own intention in bhuma samprasada adhyupadesat", ABORI 71, 1990, 318-328

23.1.272 P. George Victor, Social Philosophy of Vedanta: A Study of the Upanisads, Bhagavadgita, Brahmasutras and Samkara's Commentaries on Them. Calcutta 1991

23.1.273 Rampada Chattopadhyay, A Vaisnava Interpretation of the Brahmasutras' Vedanta and Theism. Translated by Kanti Chattopadhyaya. Leiden 1992

23.1.273.1 Citrarekha V. Kher, "Buddhism as presented by Badarayana in the Brahmasutras", BPBS 475-478

23.1.273.2 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Prakasatman's Vivarana, Akhandananda's Tattvadipana, Padmapada's Pancapadika, and Visnubhattopadhyaya's Rjuvivarana, by S. Subrahmanya Sastri. Mt. Abu 1992

23.1.274 George C. Adams, The Structure and Meaning of Badarayana's Brahmasutra. (A Translation and Analysis of Adhyaya I). Delhi 1993 

23.1.275 Madhan M. Agrawal, "A synthetic account of different interpretations of Brahmasutras 2.2.42-45", Sambhasa 14, 1993, 61-72.

23.1.275.5 Edited, with editor's commentary, by Samanithapadhyaya Ghimira Vyasa. Kathmandu 1993

23.1.275.7 Diane Collinson and Robert Wilkinson, Badarayana section, 350P, 1994, 47-52

23.1.275.8 Enrica Garzilli, "Badarayana's Vedantasutra", GWP

23.1.276 R.K.Das Gupta, "Swami Vivekananda on Badarayana's Brahma-Sutra", BRMIC 46.1, 1995, 3-12

23.1.277 Edited, with editor''s commentary, by Vidyananda Giri. Rishikesh 1995

23.1.277.5 Enrica Garzilli, "B¹dar¹yaªa's Ved¹ntasØtras", Grosses Werklexikon der Philosophie (ed. F. Volpi), Munchen 1995

23.1.278 Vijay Pandeya, "Visayavakyas of the Brahmasutras", BhV 55, 1995, 91-108

23.1.278.5 Veneemadhava Shastri Joshi, "Samkhya issues in the Brahmasutras", JKU 39, 1996, 70-75

23.1.279 Edited and translated by Lokeswarananda. BRMIC 47, 1996, 492-493; 48, 1997: 30, 90, 146, 197, 255, 306, 345, 394, 442, 495, 541, 591; 49, 1998: 33, 89, 143, 191, 229, 282, 325, 365, 417, 470, 527, 563; 49-50, 1999: 19, 179, 23.

23.1.279.5 Krishna Bhattacharya, Upanisanmulakam Brahmasutra. Kalikata 1996

23.1.280 Edited, with Samkara's Bhasya, Govindananda's Ratnaprabha, Visnudevanandagiri's Govindaprasadini and Vidyananada Giri's commentary. Hrsikesa, U.P. 1997

23.1.281 George Adams, "Interesting the Brahma Sutras of Badarayana", Darshana 37.2, 1997, 68-80

23.1.288 Edited, with Nimbarka's Vedantaparijhtasaurabha, Srinivasa's Vedantakaustubha, Kesavakasmiri's Prabha, Amolakarama's Bhavadipika, by Madan Mohan Agarwal. Four volumes. Delhi 2000

23.1.288 Kumudini, Doctrines of Samkarabhasya and Bhaskarabhasya on Brahmasutras. Delhi 2001

23.1.290 Edited and translated by Lakshmidatta Dikshita. Delhi 2001

23.1.291 Edited, with Vallabha's Anubhasya, by Gosvami Lalit Krishnaji. Delhi 2001

23.1.291.5 Translated by Madan Mohan Arawala. 6SystIP 655-803

23.1.292 Chapter One edited by Vidyananda Giri. Rsikesh 2001

23.1.292.5 Edited and translated by Vidyanand Sarasvati, The Brahmasutra. The Philosoph of God-Realisation. Delhi 2001

23.1.295 M. Prabhakara Rao, "Inconsistencies in the Brahmasutra and Samkarabhasya, with special reference to the competence of sudras", JICPR 19.2, 2002, 139-156

23.1.298 Edited with Baladeva Vidyabhusana's Gobindabhasya by Shyam Das. Vrndavan 2003

23.1.300 S. Sankaranarayanan, "Badarayana and Vyasa on the authors as authors of the Brahmasutras: a historical analysis", ALB 67, 2003, 91-146

23.1.301 Edited with Sarvajnatman's Samksepasariraka, Madhusudana Sarasvatiss Sarasamgraha, Gobindananda Giri's Tattvaprakasika and Vidyananda Giri's Lalita, by B. Visnuprakasa. Rsikesa 2002?

23.1.302 Mandalika Venkatesvan Sastri, "The doctrine of maya in the Brahmasutra", TVOS 29, 2004, 72-76

23.1.303 Sailaja Bapat, "Brahmasutras' interpretions: a new approach", FacInd 167-176

23.1.304 N. Veezhinathan, "Jijnasadhikarana", TVOS 29, 2004, 133-147; 30, 2005, 150-165

23.1.305 S. Balakrishnan, "The role of nididhyasana vis-a-vis self-knowledge", TVOS 30, 2005, 126-131


23A.Author Unknown (50 A.D.?)

   1.Bodhisattvapitaka

23A.0.1 Kusumita Priscilla Pedersen, The 'Dhyana' Chapter of the Bodhisattvapitakasutra. Ph.D.Dissertatin, Columbia University 1976

23A.0.2 Ulrich Pagel, The Bodhisattvapitaka and the Aksayamatinirdesa: continuity and change in Buddhist sutras", BF 3, 1994, 333-374

23A.0.3 Ulrich Pagel, The Bodhisattvapitaka: Its Doctrines, Practices and Their Position in Mahayana Literature. Tring, U.K. 1995

23A.1.1 Cf. EnIndPh 8, 1999, 79

23A.1.2 Ulrich Pagel, "Three Bodhisattvapitaka fragments from Tabo: observations on a West Tibetan manuscript tradition", JIABS 22.1, 1999, 165-210