Return to Home Page
Key Legislative Reforms - new property and organizational forms cont.
Law on Commodity Exchanges and Exchange-Brokered Trade, adopted by Russian Parliament Feb 20, 1992
Placed these new structures on a legal foundation
Guaranteed considerable freedom in areas of self-management, rules of exchange-brokered trade and free prices.
Banned exchanges from any type of economic activity not specific to them
Banned from regular trade and middleman trade activity
Capital investment only allowed in organization and development of exchange-brokered trade and market infrastructure
Stock purchases and subsidiaries forbidden
Banks forbidden from participating in commodity exchange activities

Key Legislative Reforms dealing with Destatization & Privatization
Law of Destatization & Privatization, USSR Supreme Soviet, July 1, 1991
Provided for conversion or restructuring of state enterprises in variety of new property forms
Joint-stock companies
leased enterprises
Cooperatives
Redemption of leased property by the lessees,
Outright sales of enterprises by competitive bid or auction
Enterprise workers granted preferential right to acquire shares & determine procedure for privatization
Privatization committees tasks -catalog, assign, & register firms into categories of (initially) state property
Attempted to assess market values for housing

Key Legislative Reforms dealing with Destatization & Privatization cont.
Voucher scheme(s)
YelÕtsin - Òmillions of owners, not a small group of millionairesÓ
Each citizen got one voucher valued at 10,000 rubles
Vouchers for direct purchase of shares, indirect via investment companies, or sell voucher for cash
August 31, 1992 Russian Deputy Prime Minister Anatolii Chubais  (400 rubles/$1 - Oct 22, 1992) claims vouchers would be worth 150,000 to 200,000 rubles
Instant secondary market - vouchers discounted to 6100 rubles on first day of trading - October 1, 1992
Oct. 9, 1992, Russian Parliament guarantees face value of privatization vouchers and specified that vouchers could be used to purchase apartments and land
If enterprise had fixed assets >50 million rubles & >1000 employees, then privatization plans were to be completed by Oct. 1, 1992

Key Legislative Reforms dealing with Destatization & Privatization cont.
June 1992 ÒState Program for the Privatization of State and Municipal Enterprises of the Russian Federation for 1992Ó
Decree ÒOn Organizational Measures for the Conversion of State Enterprises and Voluntary Associations of State Enterprises into Joint-Stock CompaniesÓ & ÒStatute on the Commercialization of State Enterprises and Their Simultaneous Conversion into Open-Type Joint-Stock CompaniesÓ signed by YelÕstin July 1, 1992
9 key objectives:
1) generate a social stratum of private owners to facilitate the creation of a socially and consumer-oriented market economy,
2) increase efficiency of enterprises via privatization,
3) provide a social support & protection net for the population,
4) develop a social infrastructure using money obtained from the privatization sales,
5) promote ruble and general financial stabilization,
6) create a competitive economic atmosphere,
7) de-monopolize the economy,
8) attract foreign investment, &
9) create conditions needed to broaden the scope of privatization in 1993-1994

Key Legislative Reforms dealing with Destatization & Privatization cont.
June 1992 ÒState Program for the Privatization of State and Municipal Enterprises of the Russian Federation for 1992Ó
5 property classes
Objects and enterprises prohibited from being privatized -mineral and water resources, gold reserve, Central Bank, telecommunication facilities, military property, objects of cultural & historical heritage
Requires consent of Russian government or one Federation republics, a Deputy Prime Minister, State Property Committee, and appropriate ministry – weapons production & repair facilities, fuel and energy complexes, commercial banks, news agencies, nuclear power manufacturing facilities (why do you think added restrictions were placed on these sorts of objects and firms?)
Enterprises having dominant or monopoly position in national and local markets – education institutions, breweries & distilleries, air, rail, and water transport enterprises, firms having more than 10,000 enterprises – privatization requires decision of Russian FederationÕs State Property Committee after consultation with relevant ministries
Enterprises such as pharmacies, public baths, urban mass transit system – require involvement of local privatization programs and consent of local property management committees
Enterprises and facilities subject to mandatory privatization
Consumer service enterprises, light industry, food industry, public catering, wholesale and retail trade
Money-losing enterprises of all sectors, moth-balled facilities, unfinished facilities
What is money-losing or money-making under soft-budget constraints
3 property class missing: state farms (sovkhozy), housing, & land

Three options offered by State  Privatization Program
By Nov. 1, 1992, firms preparing privatization plans were to be ÒcommercializedÓ or transformed into joint-stock companies.
Option 1 - employees given free of charge, non-voting shares worth 25% of equity, can buy up to additional 10% of equity at a 30% discount from book value,  totaling a maximum of 6 months minimum wages, top managers can purchase up to 5% of equity at book value, up to 100% of employeesÕ and managerÕs payments can be made in vouchers;
Option 2 - a group of employees purchases 51% of equity at a price determined by the State Committee for the Administration of State Property (GKI) and up to 50% of payment can be made in vouchers; and
Option 3 - (limited to enterprises with less than 200 employees and a book value of between 1 million and 50 million rubles) one-year lease contract giving employees an option to buy 20% of equity at a 30% discount of book value and up to 100% of payments can be made in vouchers

Problems
IMF issues, inflation, stable currency
Ruble overhang, suppressed inflation
Wage arrears
Viktor Gerashchenko (Head of Central Bank) vs Yegor Gaidar (when he was Acting Prime Minister)
Ruble printing press vs IMF austerity program
Ruble crash in late 1990s

Red Square & St. BasilÕs
The Research Questions
Ferrous Metallurgy
Schematic View of
Iron & Steel
Production
SISEM Flow model
SISEM Objective Function
Constraints  #1
Constraints  #2
Constraints  #3
Constraints  #4
Constraints  #5
Variables #1
Variables #2
Variables #3
Variables #4
Sub-system cost questions
Sub-system cost functions
Transportation Cost Data
Ore types (#1)
Ore types (#2)
Ore types (#3)
Ore deposits #1
Ore
deposits
# 2
Marketable Ore
 1965-1980
Soviet Ore Exports 1960-1979
Iron Ore Production Data
Iron Ore Enrichment Process
Coking Coal Production
Coke
Manufacture
Coking Coal
& Iron Ore
Exports
Scrap
metal
sources
Pig 
Iron
Production
 (1970)
Steel Production
 Data
 for
 1970
Steel Production Data for 1990
Steel Production Data for 1990 (page 2)
Modeled Changes in Crude Iron Ore Production 1980-1990
Changes in Iron Ore Enrichment 1980-1990
Modeled optimal coking coal production
1980-1990
Changes in Coking Coal Production 1980-1990
Coal Coking production & flows for 1980 & 1990
Changes in Coke Production 1980-1990
Coke Manufacture & Flows to Pig Iron Plants (1980)
Coke Manufacture & Flows to Pig Iron Plants (1990)
Fe-Ore Production & Flows to Steel Plants (1990)
Estimated Pig Iron Demand by Regional Nodes
Changes in Scrap Metal Utilization 1980-1990
Modeled changes in Electricity Consumption 1980-1990
Modeled Changes in Natural Gas Consumption
 1980-1990
Changes in Pig Iron Production 1980-1990
Modeled Steel Production & Flows for 1990